Ranked by our pick, then checks passed, then cost. Time and cost count every try; each dot is one check, in the order listed below (filled: passed, half: partly, empty: failed). Click a model for its notes.
A plain slate-and-cream board with a side panel, a move list in proper notation and buttons to resign, offer a draw or claim one. It refused both illegal moves, announced "White wins! Checkmate." after Qxf7#, castled and took en passant correctly, and it also handled our check, promotion and stalemate probes ("Stalemate: no legal moves, and the king is not in check."). Nothing went wrong in our tests, and it was one of the quickest and cheapest working answers of the first ten.
2.0 min · 7,516 output tokens (790 thinking) · $0.075
A plain cream-and-green board with "White to move" above it, a New game button and the result below, but no move list, undo or flip. It refused both illegal moves, announced "White wins by checkmate." after Qxf7#, castled on both sides and took en passant, and our probes passed too: Black could not ignore Qh5+, promotion offers four pieces, and the ten-move stalemate ends with "Draw by stalemate." The board is laid out badly, though: a rank with no pieces on it shrinks to a strip, so at the start the four middle ranks are less than half the height of the others. The cheapest of the first twelve answers, at $0.0046 in 69 seconds.
69 s · 9,271 output tokens (3,047 thinking) · $0.005
Added 8 October 2026.
A brown wooden board with a dark side panel, a move list in standard notation ("4. Qxf7#") and resign and new-game buttons, but no undo or flip. All four sequences played correctly, and so did our probes: Black could not ignore Qh5+, promotion offers a choice of four pieces, and the ten-move stalemate ends with "Stalemate! The game is a draw." The status reads "White to move", adds "(in check!)" when needed, and shows "Checkmate! White wins." at the end. The cheapest of the first eleven answers, at about a cent.
91 s · 22,272 output tokens (13,195 thinking) · $0.011
Added 8 October 2026.
A plain cream and tan board on a dark page, with "White to move." above it and a New Game button below; the chosen piece turns gold and dots show its moves. It refused both illegal moves and a black move on White's turn, played Scholar's mate to "Checkmate! White wins.", castled on both sides and took en passant, and our probes passed too: Black had to answer Qh5+, promotion offers four pieces and the ten-move stalemate ends "Stalemate! It's a draw." There is no move list, undo or flip. 101 seconds, $0.015.
101 s · 42,822 output tokens (36,160 thinking) · $0.015
Added 19 October 2026.
A wooden board with a small side panel listing moves as "e2-e4" and a yellow "Check!" or green "Checkmate! White wins." under the turn line. All four sequences and our extra probes played correctly. It was the cheapest of the first ten answers, at about two cents.
2.8 min · 30,146 output tokens (21,274 thinking) · $0.024
A warm wooden board on a dark page, with a status pill ("White to move", "Black to move — Check!"), a king that glows red in check and a yellow "Checkmate — White wins!" line. It refused both illegal moves, played Scholar's mate to the end, castled on both sides and took en passant, and our probes passed too: Black had to answer Qh5+, promotion offers four pieces and the ten-move stalemate ends "Stalemate — it's a draw." It also handles the fifty-move, repetition and insufficient-material draws. There is no move list, undo or flip. 81 seconds, $0.031.
81 s · 26,025 output tokens (17,945 thinking) · $0.031
Added 19 October 2026.
A green and cream board with a status line, "New game" and "Claim draw". It refused both illegal moves, announced "Checkmate. White wins!", castled and took en passant correctly, and it also got our check, promotion and stalemate tries right. There is no move list, and empty rows are squashed, so the squares change height as pieces move. 74 seconds, $0.033.
74 s · 6,640 output tokens (1,124 thinking) · $0.033
Added 27 October 2026.
A dark green page with a cream and sage board, a card for each player, a status panel ("White to move", "Check — Black"), a move list in standard notation, and undo, flip, resign and draw buttons. It refused both illegal moves, played Scholar's mate to "White wins by checkmate", castled on both sides and took en passant, and our probes passed too: Black had to answer Qh5+, promotion offers four pieces and the ten-move stalemate ends "Draw by stalemate". The result banner covers the back rank, and the black pieces are hard to make out on the dark squares. One try, 7.9 minutes on OpenRouter's free route, so the time is not representative; $0.035 at list prices.
7.9 min · 57,569 output tokens (42,514 thinking) · $0.035
Added 19 October 2026.
A clean board under a "White to move" bar, with the moves written in one line beneath it. Every sequence worked; checkmate and stalemate each dim the board behind a "Game Over" box, and promotion opens a piece picker. A correct, plain answer and the second cheapest of the first ten.
3.9 min · 12,265 output tokens (5,148 thinking) · $0.052
A tidy board with a captured-pieces tray, a material count and a highlighted move list. Every rule worked, but once the game ends the status still reads "Black to move" above "Checkmate - White wins". It took 23 minutes.
23 min · 62,420 output tokens (43,580 thinking) · $0.131
A green and cream board with clear contrasting pieces and a turn banner. It rejected e2-e5 and the blocked f1-c4, announced White wins after Scholar’s mate, moved the rook when castling and removed the captured pawn on en passant. These were played through the board, from a fresh game for each sequence. 1 try, 2.4 min, $0.1358.
2.4 min · 13,558 output tokens (2,988 thinking) · $0.136
Added 11 November 2026.
The most minimal answer: a board, a "White to move" line under the title and a New Game button, with no move list or undo. All four sequences played correctly, and check, promotion and stalemate ("Stalemate - it's a draw.") all work. It has the fewest extras of the working boards, but nothing in it is wrong.
3.7 min · 19,036 output tokens (11,867 thinking) · $0.267
A green board in a dark frame with a status card, a dot for whose turn it is, the last move highlighted and a red glow on a king in check. All four sequences played correctly, and so did our check, promotion and stalemate tries. It keeps no move list and has only a new game button. The judge, which saw part of the code, doubted promotion; it works, with a named choice of four pieces. 12 minutes, $0.27.
12 min · 26,774 output tokens (18,255 thinking) · $0.268
Added 27 October 2026.
"The Checkmate Room": a green felt board in a wooden frame, player cards with a "to move" tag, a score sheet and a gold "Checkmate 1-0" card at the end. Every rule we tried worked, but the h-file sticks out past the right edge of the frame, and it took almost 20 minutes to write.
20 min · 46,816 output tokens (33,879 thinking) · $0.281
A brown wooden board with a side panel, an undo button and a move list ending in "1-0". Every sequence played correctly, and checkmate brings up a "Checkmate! White wins." box with a "View board" button so you can still see the final position. It is as complete as GPT-6.1 Sol and just as fast, but cost about four times as much.
2.0 min · 14,814 output tokens (4,435 thinking) · $0.297
A dark wooden board with "Black" and "White" bars above and below it, a status box ("White to move", "Checkmate - White wins"), a move list, undo and flip. All four sequences played correctly, and Scholar's mate dims the board behind a "Checkmate / White wins" box. It sent code only on its third try, after two tries with no code; that third try took over nine minutes and cost $0.29, and all three took 26 minutes and $0.63.
9.5 min · 47,955 output tokens (36,804 thinking) · $0.288 for this answer; 26 min and $0.631 over 3 tries
Took 3 tries: sent no code at 64,000 tokens; sent no code at 64,000 tokens; finished at 64,000 tokens.Billed for 1,335 input tokens, about 1,212 more than the other models for the same prompt. We sent no system prompt, and the extra is there on every one of its requests, so it is text the provider adds itself.
A compact board with the status in a bar above it, which turns red for "Black to move - Check!" and green for "Checkmate! White wins." All four sequences played correctly, and it offers promotion with a choice of four pieces. It is correct, with undo and a flip button, but it was the most expensive of the first eighteen answers by far.
2.9 min · 17,160 output tokens (7,534 thinking) · $0.859
A brown and cream board between two player bars that show whose move it is and the pieces each side has taken, with a status line, a move list in standard notation, undo, a flip button and keyboard control. It refused e2-e5, the blocked Bf1-c4 and a click on a black piece out of turn, announced "Checkmate" and "White wins" in a panel after Qxf7#, castled for both sides, refused to castle once the king had moved, and took en passant correctly. Our check, promotion and stalemate tries were right too: a choice of four pieces, and "Stalemate" with "Black has no legal move". Nothing went wrong. 4.7 minutes and $1.27, the dearest of the first nineteen answers on this page.
4.7 min · 31,660 output tokens (18,071 thinking) · $1.268
Added 10 November 2026.
29 s · 19,270 output tokens (11,682 thinking) · $0.010
Added 9 November 2026.
The page shows a "White's Turn" bar and an empty dark square where the board should be. The script crashes as it loads ("Cannot access 'chess' before initialization"): the game draws the board before the game object exists, and the board never appears. The New Game button throws the same error, so no move can be played.
Failed every check.
110 s · 16,631 output tokens (6,790 thinking) · $0.062
40 s · 6,518 output tokens · $0.065
Added 13 October 2026.
One answer per model, at each model's default settings unless the card says otherwise, through OpenRouter. If an answer ran out of room or stopped short, we asked again with more room, then with thinking off, and say so. This is a quick look, not a benchmark: run it again and every answer will differ. For measured results, see our benchmarks.
What we checked, by trying each answer ourselves: Refuses illegal moves; Detects checkmate and announces the result; Castling works; En passant works; Shows whose turn it is. A partial pass counts as half.
All but one of the boards handled the four sequences we played: illegal moves, Scholar's mate, castling and en passant. Of the first ten, eight also passed our check, promotion and stalemate tries; Grok 4.7, which only sent code on its third try, was not put through those. With correctness level, speed and cost decide. GPT-6.1 Sol is our pick: correct throughout, with a move list in standard notation and draw and resign buttons, in two minutes for $0.075. Claude Opus 5.5 is just as good and about as fast (two minutes) but cost $0.30. DeepSeek V4.1 Flash ($0.024) and Muse Spark 1.3 ($0.052) were the cheapest fully working boards until Claude Haiku 5.5 and GPT-6 Luna, both added on 8 October, played every test correctly for $0.011 and $0.0046; Luna's board squashes its empty rows. DeepSeek V4.1 Flash 1017, added on 19 October, also played every test correctly ($0.031), but keeps no move list. MiniMax M3.1 Flash, added the same day on OpenRouter's free route, passed every test too, with a move list, undo and draw buttons, and so did Mercury 3, added the same day, on a bare board ($0.015). GPT-6.1 Terra, added on 27 October, played every test correctly ($0.033), but keeps no move list and squashes its empty rows. Kimi K3.1 Pro, added the same day, did too, on a clear board with the last move marked, but took 12 minutes and cost $0.27. Claude Fable 5.2, added on 10 November, played every test correctly as well, with a move list, captured pieces, undo and a flip button, but at $1.27 it is the dearest of the first nineteen boards. Claude Fable 5.1 cost $0.86, while Qwen3.8 Max (20 minutes) and Mistral Large 4 (23 minutes) took far longer to get the same result.
Gemini 3.8 Flash is the one failure: it crashes as the page loads and never draws a board.