Ranked by our pick, then checks passed, then cost. Time and cost count every try; each dot is one check, in the order listed below (filled: passed, half: partly, empty: failed). Click a model for its notes.
A restrained, editorial page ("A photo book in a week.") built around the offer, with a day-by-day timeline from confirm to doormat and a sample book whose title and cloth colour you can change. It invents no reviews, ratings or customer counts, and it says "no extra pages sold as an upgrade". The only hedge is "Delivery is shown before you pay", which leaves postage open.
13 min · 48,825 output tokens (33,027 thinking) · $0.294
Billed for 1,329 input tokens, about 1,210 more than the other models for the same prompt. We sent no system prompt, and the extra is there on every one of its requests, so it is text the provider adds itself.
A warm cream page in serif type ("Turn your camera roll into a book you'll keep.") with a "Make my photo book – £19" button in the hero, a drawn open book and phone, three steps, sample spreads, a price card and an FAQ. £19, forty pages and a week hold throughout, with no testimonials, ratings, customer counts or extras, and nothing overflows at 390 px. Its "Create a mini layout" button opens a working preview: choose photos from your device and it lays the first four out as pages, without uploading anything. The copy leans on stock lines ("Phones are made for moments. Books are made for memories."). One try, 4.3 minutes on OpenRouter's free route, so the time is not representative; $0.026 at list prices.
4.3 min · 42,977 output tokens (14,713 thinking) · $0.026
Added 19 October 2026.
A calm green and cream page ("Your photos deserve more than a scroll.") with drawn photo spreads, three steps, a price panel and a four-question FAQ. The offer stays exact everywhere (£19, 40 pages, delivered in a week) and it invents no reviews, ratings, customer counts or extras. Every "Start your book" button opens a working preview: pick photos from your device and they appear as thumbnails, with a plain note that ordering is not available in this demo. Nothing overflows at 390 px. The copy is warm but general, and it says less about what you actually get than Grok's. 2.0 minutes, $0.054.
2.0 min · 10,864 output tokens (535 thinking) · $0.054
Added 27 October 2026.
A neat cream page with a "Create Your Book — £19" button and a clickable spread preview. The price and week hold throughout, but the page makes up "4.9 / 5 from 18,400+ books printed", five-star reviews with full names, "GUARANTEED 7-DAY UK DELIVERY" and a print site in Sheffield. The footer says © 2025.
2.8 min · 19,713 output tokens (1,701 thinking) · $0.074
A long page ("Your photos, made to keep."): a drawn open book with a £19 seal, three coloured steps, a "Not just the highlights" panel, a price card, five FAQ answers and an orange sign-up band. The offer holds throughout, with no reviews, ratings or extra charges, and it works at 390 px with the call to action in the first screen. It does add product details the brief never gave: a "sturdy soft-touch cover", matte pages, and captions and automatic layouts. Both main buttons jump to an email box for an app link, and our sandboxed frame blocks forms, so here that box does nothing (opened as a file, it confirms the address). 14 minutes, $0.33.
14 min · 33,048 output tokens (14,555 thinking) · $0.331
Added 27 October 2026.
A bookish page with a sample you can page through, a parcel-label price card and a copies counter that totals correctly ("Make 3 books — £57"). The offer holds throughout, but it adds "4.9 — from 2,318 books already on mantelpieces", a made-up ISBN and a reprint-or-refund promise, and the book is called both A5 hardcover and A5 landscape. It needed a second try: the first stopped at the 64,000-token limit.
34 min · 117,509 output tokens (77,106 thinking) · $0.246 for this answer; 57 min and $0.379 over 2 tries
Took 2 tries: ran out of room at 64,000 tokens; finished at 128,000 tokens.
A rich page with a photo picker you can tap, a receipt-style order summary that adds up to £19.00, and a delivery date worked out from today. The offer is consistent, but the page invents "18,432 books posted", "4.9 / 5 from 2,300+ reviews" and a Cornish studio. One testimonial ("Ordered on a Sunday night, holding it the next Monday") describes eight days. The "Get Driftwood" menu button is orange on orange.
6.7 min · 35,532 output tokens (17,392 thinking) · $0.533
A cream and rust page in serif type ("Your camera roll, in print by next week.") with the offer in the first paragraph, two download buttons in the first screen, a drawn phone and open book with a £19 badge, three steps, a spec list, a price card and six FAQ answers. £19, 40 pages and a week hold everywhere, closed FAQ answers included, with no reviews, ratings, customer counts, guarantees or extra prices ("That's the whole price list"). A "Have a go" section works: tap drawn photos in a camera roll and they fill the pages of a sample book. Nothing overflows at 390 px. It does add product details the brief never gave: a 20 by 20 cm softcover, 170gsm matte paper, room for about 80 photos, and a warning before you order if a photo is too blurry. The download buttons go nowhere. 9.4 minutes and $2.37, the dearest of the first nineteen answers on this page.
9.4 min · 59,245 output tokens (36,255 thinking) · $2.371
Added 10 November 2026.
A soft green-and-cream page ("Keep the days you almost forgot.") with a drawn book and polaroids in the hero, three steps, a price card and a four-question FAQ. It repeats £19, 40 pages and a week throughout and invents no reviews, customer counts or extra prices; it does add that delivery is included, a row of five decorative stars with no rating behind them, and a © 2025 footer. The phone menu opens and nothing scrolls sideways at 390 px, but there the "40 pages of your kind of lovely" label covers the title of the hero book. The cheapest of the first twelve answers, at $0.006 in 84 seconds.
- ◐ Works on a phone: nothing overflows or overlaps at 390 px wide (partly)
84 s · 12,269 output tokens (561 thinking) · $0.006
Added 8 October 2026.
A cream and teal page ("Your photos, beautifully bound.") with a "Start your book — £19" button in the hero and the header, a grid of pastel tiles around a "Driftwood 40 pages" book, and sections that fade in as you scroll: three steps, four reasons, one price card, three testimonials and a teal closing band. It works at 390 px with nothing spilling over. But it invents a lot: "4.9 on the App Store", a money-back guarantee, free UK delivery, 170gsm FSC paper, named testimonials ("Lucy, Brighton") and a studio in St Ives, and under "One book. One price. Zero surprises." it sells extra copies at £12 each. One of the quickest pages here, at 37 seconds, $0.0075.
- ◐ States the offer correctly (£19 for a 40-page book, delivered in a week) with no conflicting prices or promises (partly)
37 s · 21,553 output tokens (14,777 thinking) · $0.008
Added 19 October 2026.
A calm cream-and-teal page ("Your camera roll, finally on paper.") with a CSS hardback and polaroids, four steps, gradient sample spreads and a "Make my book for £19" button. It repeats the offer throughout and invents no reviews, ratings, customer counts or extra prices; it does add that delivery is included and the paper is heavy and matte, and its reply lists what it made up. The header's "Make my book" button is brown on dark teal and can't be read, and on a phone the polaroid captions spill over their photos. The fastest and cheapest of the first eleven answers, at $0.008 in 64 seconds.
- ◐ Works on a phone: nothing overflows or overlaps at 390 px wide (partly)
64 s · 15,863 output tokens (1,625 thinking) · $0.008
Added 8 October 2026.
A warm cream page in serif type ("Your camera roll, made into something you can hold.") with a "Make my book — £19" button in the hero, a drawn hardback, three steps, sample spreads, a dark price card and an FAQ. £19, forty pages and a week hold throughout, and nothing overflows at 390 px. But under "One honest price … no premium paper upsell" it sells extra pages at £3 for eight, and it adds free reprints, three five-star testimonials with names and towns, a support address and a © 2025 footer. 109 seconds, $0.038.
- ◐ States the offer correctly (£19 for a 40-page book, delivered in a week) with no conflicting prices or promises (partly)
109 s · 31,991 output tokens (17,889 thinking) · $0.038
Added 19 October 2026.
A short, warm page ("Your camera roll. Now with a spine.") with illustrated polaroids and an orange "Try a book preview" button. It repeats the offer exactly and invents nothing: no reviews, no ratings, no extras. But at about 400 words it is thin, and on a phone it scrolls 11 px sideways while the £19 sticker clips its own "40 good pages" label.
- ◐ Works on a phone: nothing overflows or overlaps at 390 px wide (partly)
3.1 min · 12,232 output tokens (516 thinking) · $0.122
A polished page with a phone-and-book hero, a sample book you can flip through and a detailed spec table (21 cm hardback, 200gsm, made in Bristol). It says "the price you see is the price you pay" but then sells extra copies at £14 and 20 more pages for £6. It also adds beta-tester quotes, a 30-day refund and a promise to refund delivery if a book is late.
- ◐ States the offer correctly (£19 for a 40-page book, delivered in a week) with no conflicting prices or promises (partly)
6.4 min · 41,397 output tokens (14,799 thinking) · $0.828
A tidy, conventional page with a green hardback in the hero and a "Make a book — £19" button in the header. Under the heading "Forty pages. One price. No upsell." it charges 40p for each extra page and £4 for worldwide shipping that takes 10 to 14 days. "Order by Sunday night and it's with you the following Monday" also stretches the week. It was the cheapest and fastest of the first ten answers.
- ✗ States the offer correctly (£19 for a 40-page book, delivered in a week) with no conflicting prices or promises
100 s · 32,175 output tokens (20,350 thinking) · $0.039
A friendly page with a theme picker and a copies counter, but the offer keeps changing. A "Free UK delivery" launch banner sits above a price already sold as "£19 all-in". The page also adds 2 for £36, 3 for £51, a £4 four-day rush, £3 off for joining the waitlist and invented numbers (3,200+ reviews, 12,000 books, 1,240 trees). The "Get the app" button in the desktop menu is dark text on dark green and can't be read.
- ✗ States the offer correctly (£19 for a 40-page book, delivered in a week) with no conflicting prices or promises
109 s · 10,457 output tokens (1,595 thinking) · $0.045
The most crafted desktop page: a scrolling ticker, a Monday-to-Sunday print timeline, a tap-to-pick app demo and postcard-style testimonials. It sells extra pages (+8 for £4) and a £15 second copy while also promising "no upsell at checkout", and it invents a crew of nine with a Heidelberg press. On a phone the hero photos collapse to thin slivers, leaving stray captions in a big empty gap.
- ◐ States the offer correctly (£19 for a 40-page book, delivered in a week) with no conflicting prices or promises (partly)
- ◐ Works on a phone: nothing overflows or overlaps at 390 px wide (partly)
15 min · 38,639 output tokens (17,138 thinking) · $0.232
A polished cream and orange photo-book page with a large opening CTA, a live cover preview and a download modal. At 390 pixels wide it fits without horizontal overflow or visible overlap, and the CTA opens the modal. The main £19, 40-page, one-week offer is present, but it also invents a £14 extra-copy offer, free tracked delivery, materials, order counts and customer reviews. 1 try, 5.2 min, $0.2389.
- ✗ States the offer correctly (£19 for a 40-page book, delivered in a week) with no conflicting prices or promises
5.2 min · 23,870 output tokens (1,558 thinking) · $0.239
Added 11 November 2026.
The best-written copy ("Your best photos are stuck on your phone. Let a few out."), with the offer in a pill above the headline and a clear "What £19 gets you" list. It adds a £15 second copy, a reprint-or-refund promise and three named testimonials. On a phone the page scrolls 68 px sideways: the hero book hangs off the left edge and the email "Send the link" button is cut off on the right.
- ◐ States the offer correctly (£19 for a 40-page book, delivered in a week) with no conflicting prices or promises (partly)
- ◐ Works on a phone: nothing overflows or overlaps at 390 px wide (partly)
4.6 min · 23,578 output tokens (4,132 thinking) · $1.180
31 s · 18,536 output tokens (4,714 thinking) · $0.009
Added 9 November 2026.
113 s · 17,308 output tokens · $0.173
Added 13 October 2026.
One answer per model, at each model's default settings unless the card says otherwise, through OpenRouter. If an answer ran out of room or stopped short, we asked again with more room, then with thinking off, and say so. This is a quick look, not a benchmark: run it again and every answer will differ. For measured results, see our benchmarks.
What we checked, by trying each answer ourselves: States the offer correctly (£19 for a 40-page book, delivered in a week) with no conflicting prices or promises; Works on a phone: nothing overflows or overlaps at 390 px wide; A clear call to action near the top. A partial pass counts as half.
Grok 4.7 wrote the most trustworthy page. Every section comes back to £19, forty pages and a week, and it adds nothing a real company would have to defend: no ratings, no customer counts, no extra prices. It took 13 minutes and cost $0.29. Claude Fable 5.1 has the best copy, and Claude Opus 5.5 and Qwen 3.8 Max made richer pages, but all three add paid extras and invented testimonials, and Fable 5.1 and Qwen both break at phone width. GPT-6.1 Sol is the other clean answer of the first ten, at $0.12 in about three minutes, but it is short and scrolls slightly sideways on a phone. MiniMax M3.1 Flash, added on 19 October on OpenRouter's free route, is as clean as Grok's, with no reviews or extras, works on a phone, and adds a working preview that lays out your own photos; Grok stays our pick for its plainer, more specific copy. GPT-6.1 Terra, added on 27 October, is clean too, with a working photo preview, for $0.054, but its copy is more general than Grok's. Kimi K3.1 Pro, added the same day, invents no reviews either, but adds a soft-touch cover and matte pages, at $0.33 and 14 minutes. Claude Fable 5.2, added on 10 November, is the best-looking of the clean pages, with no reviews or extra prices, a working photo demo and a tidy phone layout, but it prints a spec list the brief never gave (20 by 20 cm, softcover, 170gsm paper), took 9.4 minutes and cost $2.37; Grok stays our pick for adding less.
Inventing social proof was the norm: seven of the first ten pages carry testimonials, and four print a star rating or a customer count (Gemini's "18,400+ books", Kimi's "18,432"). Muse Spark 1.3 and DeepSeek V4.1 Flash failed the offer outright: Muse Spark stacks a free-delivery banner, multi-copy discounts, a rush fee and £3 off on top of an all-in price, and DeepSeek charges for extra pages under a "No upsell" heading. DeepSeek V4.1 Flash was still the cheapest of the first ten pages, at $0.039 in 100 seconds. DeepSeek V4.1 Flash 1017, added on 19 October, keeps the offer straight and works on a phone, but also sells extra pages, under a "one honest price" heading, and adds named five-star testimonials. Mistral Large 4 needed two tries, 57 minutes in all. Mercury 3, added the same day, was the quickest page here at 37 seconds and works on a phone, but adds an App Store rating, named testimonials and £12 extra copies under a "one price" heading.