Benchmarks / DeckBench / Kestrel Logistics

Measured by Spring Prompt

Mistral Large 4: On-time delivery: what is going wrong and what to fund

For the board and the company's three main investors. The decision it supports: whether to fund 40 more drivers or a trunk re-plan with 10 drivers.

Verdict
Not presentable
Deck rating
595
Slides
6 (brief: 5-8)
Design quality
17%

Why it is not presentable

  • Layout defect: something off the slide, colliding, too small or too faint to read
  • Showed a number the analysis does not support
  • Made a material claim the analysis does not support
  • A slide the judges rated as needing work

In detail

  • Not supported by the analysis: slide 2: chart Network OTIF: 0.938.
  • Not supported by the analysis: slide 2: chart Network OTIF: 0.932.
  • Not supported by the analysis: slide 2: chart Network OTIF: 0.918.
  • Not supported by the analysis: slide 2: chart Network OTIF: 0.925.
  • Slide 2: “Network OTIF: W31 94.8%, W32 93.8%, W33 93.2%, W34 91.8%, W35 92.5%. These intermediate network figures are not supplied by the analysis and do not match simple averages of its depot figures.” is not supported by the analysis.
  • Slide 2: “Network OTIF chart values W32 93.8%, W33 93.2%, W34 91.8%, W35 92.5%. The analysis gives only W29 and W36. The depot average gives about 94.5%, 94.0%, 92.4% and 93.2% for those weeks, so the chart puts the network below the 93% floor earlier and lower than the data shows.” is not supported by the analysis.
  • Slide 5: “Insurer's estimate of damaged-goods claims: £280k. The analysis says this estimate is not agreed and must not be quoted.” is not supported by the analysis.
  • Slide 2: “Network OTIF data for weeks 30 to 35 (95.5%, 94.8%, 93.8%, 93.2%, 91.8%, 92.5%)” is not supported by the analysis.
  1. Slide 1 of Mistral Large 4's deck
    Slide 1Download slide imageNeeds work The key-facts list has duplicated bullet markers on every item.Every bullet shows two markers ('• •'): the list bullet plus a typed bullet character
  2. Slide 2 of Mistral Large 4's deck
    Slide 2Download slide imageNeeds work The contract-floor reference line is drawn near 89.5% rather than at the labelled 93%, making the visual threshold confusing.The contract-floor line sits near 89.5% on the axis, not at 93%, so it does not match its label
  3. Slide 3 of Mistral Large 4's deck
    Slide 3Download slide imageNeeds work The title names the topic rather than stating the dominant finding shown by the chart.Bullets show two markers ('• •')
  4. Slide 4 of Mistral Large 4's deck
    Slide 4Download slide imageNeeds work The comparison table gives both proposals equal visual emphasis; the recommended option and its cost advantage are not highlighted.Bullets in the lower box show two markers ('• •')
  5. Slide 5 of Mistral Large 4's deck
    Slide 5Download slide imageAcceptable The oversized content panel leaves substantial unused space below the text, making the layout top-heavy.The content fills only the top half of the box, leaving a large empty area
  6. Slide 6 of Mistral Large 4's deck
    Slide 6Download slide imageAcceptable The next steps use both bullets and numbering, creating redundant list markers.The next steps show both a bullet and a number ('• 1.'), which is redundant