Ranked by our pick, then checks passed, then cost. Time and cost count every try; each dot is one check, in the order listed below (filled: passed, half: partly, empty: failed). Click a model for its notes.
A clean four-column grid with a different drawing for each garment: a belted trench, a pouch-front anorak, a quilted coat and a flared cape. It offers checkbox filters with counts, min and max price boxes plus quick bands ("Under £50" correctly shows the four jackets at £32 and £49), and "Also in yellow" links between colours. Every filter and sort we ran was correct, and it adds nothing that is not in the feed.
2.5 min · 17,916 output tokens (3,902 thinking) · $0.361
"North & Field": a calm shop with breadcrumbs, checkbox filters for brand, colour and size, min and max price boxes, a "Clear all" link and four sorts. Every price and rating matches the feed, and every filter, combination and sort we ran returned exactly the right jackets; an impossible pairing shows "No jackets found". It adds only a tagline and an intro line, with no claims on the products. Every jacket is drawn as the same short-sleeved shirt, and the colour and size lists sit in short scrolling boxes, so red, stone, yellow and the children's sizes stay hidden until you scroll them. The cheapest of the first twelve answers, at $0.0033.
46 s · 6,556 output tokens (1,154 thinking) · $0.003
Added 8 October 2026.
A plain "Rain jackets" page with checkbox filters for brand, colour (with swatches) and size, min and max price boxes, a reset button and five sorts. Every filter, combination and sort we ran returned exactly the right jackets, and an impossible pairing shows "0 of 12 products". Its only addition is a header line ("Waterproof shells, parkas and rain gear for every season"), with no claims on the products. The trench gets a belt and the cape its own shape, but the other jackets share one short-sleeved outline. The cheapest of the first eleven answers, at $0.0056.
46 s · 11,022 output tokens (3,492 thinking) · $0.006
Added 8 October 2026.
"Rainroom": a plain, well-spaced three-column grid with a two-handled price slider, checkbox filters and rain streaks behind each jacket. Every filter and sort was exact, and it adds nothing beyond the feed. It cost about a penny, the cheapest of the first ten answers by a wide margin.
117 s · 23,415 output tokens (15,545 thinking) · $0.013
"Rain jackets" with a breadcrumb, a short "Waterproof styles for every forecast" line, a filter panel (brand, colour and size checkboxes, four price bands and "Clear all"), five sorts and a "Showing 12 of 12" count. Every price and rating matches the feed, and every filter, combination and sort we ran returned exactly the right jackets; Little Fell over £150 shows "No products match your selected filters." Every jacket is drawn as the same hooded shape in its colour, the cape included, and the cards do not name the colour, so the pairs read as duplicates. There are no min and max price boxes. 107 seconds, $0.020.
107 s · 57,274 output tokens (51,468 thinking) · $0.020
Added 19 October 2026.
"Rain & Ridge": a teal hero with a drawn umbrella and the counts (12 styles, 5 brands, 10 colours), then a grid of twelve drawn jackets, each tagged with its colour, with sizes, star ratings and review counts. Brand and colour checkboxes with counts, size boxes, four price bands and four sorts all returned exactly the right jackets in our tests, and an impossible pairing (Little Fell over £150) shows "No jackets match those filters". Every price and rating matches the feed. All twelve jackets are the same hooded shape in different colours, so the trench and the cape look like the parkas, and the hero line about "quick-drying shells" says a little more than the feed does. One try, 5.0 minutes on OpenRouter's free route, so the time is not representative; $0.024 at list prices.
5.0 min · 39,343 output tokens (23,244 thinking) · $0.024
Added 19 October 2026.
"The rain edit.", a clean three-column shop with dropdowns for brand, colour and size and minimum and maximum price boxes. All twelve jackets show the right prices and ratings, sizes are on every card, and every filter and sort we tried gave the right jackets, with "No products found" when nothing matches. The copy stays close to the feed. The drawings are tidy, but most jackets share one hooded shape. 58 seconds, $0.026.
58 s · 5,148 output tokens (141 thinking) · $0.026
Added 27 October 2026.
"Field & Fell": a four-column grid of twelve drawn jackets with their colours tagged, where the trench gets a belt and the cape its own flared shape. Brand and colour checkboxes with counts, size chips, four price bands and four sorts all returned exactly the right jackets in our tests, and an impossible pairing shows "No rain jackets found". Every price and rating matches the feed. There are no min and max price boxes, and the only additions are an intro line and a "12 waterproof styles" tag, which says a little more than the feed does. 104 seconds, $0.036.
104 s · 29,948 output tokens (20,162 thinking) · $0.036
Added 19 October 2026.
A quiet "Field & Form" shop with a serif heading, checkbox filters, min and max price boxes and large drawn jackets in cards. Every filter and both sorts returned exactly the right jackets in our tests, and it adds only a tagline, no product claims. The cards are big, so at desktop width you see two or three jackets at a time.
95 s · 6,820 output tokens (247 thinking) · $0.069
A four-column grid with a different drawing for each garment (a belted trench, a pouch-front anorak, a spotted kids' jacket in a puddle), checkbox filters with counts, size chips grouped into adults, kids and one size, and min and max price boxes. Every filter and sort we ran returned exactly the right jackets, alone and combined. Options that would leave nothing are greyed out with a count of 0, so the page cannot be filtered down to an empty grid, and a price typed outside the range is pulled back to £32 or £189. It adds nothing that is not in the feed. As accurate as Opus 5.5's page, without its quick price bands or links between colours. 5.7 minutes and $1.48, the dearest of the first nineteen answers on this page.
5.7 min · 36,834 output tokens (21,896 thinking) · $1.479
Added 10 November 2026.
"Field & Form", with counted tick boxes for brand, colour swatches, a size menu and four price bands. All twelve jackets are right, every filter and sort worked, and a reset appears when nothing matches. It draws the garments apart well: a belted trench, a pouch anorak, a quilted coat and a cape. Sizes appear only in the filter, not on the cards, and the intro promises "insulated parkas", which the feed does not. The judge saw only the start of the code and marked it down; the page works. 10 minutes, $0.24.
- ◐ Adds no products, prices or claims that are not in the feed (partly)
10 min · 23,963 output tokens (14,855 thinking) · $0.241
Added 27 October 2026.
A neat three-column grid where brand, colour, size and both sorts all work correctly. The price filter is broken: every band shows a count of 0, and ticking any of them, even "£150 and over", empties the page to "Showing 0 of 12". A footer calls the products, prices and ratings "illustrative".
- ◐ Brand, colour, size and price filters work (partly)
8.1 min · 30,461 output tokens (22,509 thinking) · $0.457
"WetWeather.co": a tidy three-column grid with checkbox filters, colour counts and a price slider paired with number boxes. All the filters and sorts gave the right jackets. It does add "Bestseller" badges to the Ridgeback trail jackets, a sales claim the feed does not make. It was also the most expensive of the first eighteen answers by far.
- ◐ Adds no products, prices or claims that are not in the feed (partly)
2.9 min · 16,185 output tokens (3,928 thinking) · $0.816
A plain shop with counted checkboxes, including four price bands that each return the right jackets, and each product's feed ID printed under its card. Every filter and sort was correct. It adds "Free delivery over £75 • 60-day returns" to the header, and the jackets look more like short-sleeved shirts.
- ✗ Adds no products, prices or claims that are not in the feed
3.3 min · 10,393 output tokens (4,067 thinking) · $0.045
"Aerostorm" has colour swatches, size chips, a single max-price slider and an "Add" button on every card. The filters and sorts all worked. But it stamps "20K WATERPROOF" on six jackets, the city trench among them, adds a free-delivery banner, and draws every jacket with the same short-sleeved shape.
- ✗ Adds no products, prices or claims that are not in the feed
74 s · 14,167 output tokens (1,892 thinking) · $0.054
A clean white and teal shop with drawn jackets, all twelve feed entries and the correct prices and ratings. Brand, navy colour, XXL size and maximum-price filters worked, as did both directions of price and rating sort. It adds a free-delivery policy and a lifetime seam guarantee that the feed never supplied. 1 try, 3.6 min, $0.2056.
- ✗ Adds no products, prices or claims that are not in the feed
3.6 min · 20,437 output tokens (1,551 thinking) · $0.206
Added 11 November 2026.
The most styled page: "Downpour Supply Co." with a scrolling ticker, a big yellow-jacket hero, chip filters, price bands and a slider. Every filter and sort we tried worked. It surrounds the products with invented claims, though: a "10K MM / seam sealed" stamp, a "60-day storm test", "Back in stock" news for the Ridgeback jacket and a made-up weather widget. It took over 18 minutes.
- ✗ Adds no products, prices or claims that are not in the feed
18 min · 40,797 output tokens (23,923 thinking) · $0.246
An editorial "Stormline Supply" page with a large jacket hero, swatches, size chips with counts, a price slider and a basket. The filters and sorts all worked correctly. But it invents product facts: a "WATERPROOF 10,000 mm" badge, "taped seams and breathable membranes", and "New" and "Packable" tags, plus delivery terms and "Designed in Glasgow". Its first try was cut off at 64,000 tokens, and the second took 17 minutes.
- ✗ Adds no products, prices or claims that are not in the feed
17 min · 76,327 output tokens (45,856 thinking) · $0.160 for this answer; 45 min and $0.294 over 2 tries
Took 2 tries: ran out of room at 64,000 tokens; finished at 128,000 tokens.
19 s · 13,403 output tokens (6,816 thinking) · $0.007
Added 9 November 2026.
76 s · 13,135 output tokens · $0.133
Added 13 October 2026.
Grok sent no code on its first three tries, and the fourth failed with an API error. The fifth try produced a "Bracken Outfitters" page, but its script stops with an error as it loads. The filter headings are empty, no jackets appear, and it still says "Showing 12 of 12".
Failed every check.
4.7 min · 26,555 output tokens (15,485 thinking) · $0.160 for this answer; 5.0 min and $0.172 over 5 tries
Took 5 tries: sent no code at 64,000 tokens; sent no code at 64,000 tokens; sent no code at 128,000 tokens; failed at 128,000 tokens, thinking off; finished at 64,000 tokens.Billed for 1,764 input tokens, about 1,179 more than the other models for the same prompt. We sent no system prompt, and the extra is there on every one of its requests, so it is text the provider adds itself.
One answer per model, at each model's default settings unless the card says otherwise, through OpenRouter. If an answer ran out of room or stopped short, we asked again with more room, then with thinking off, and say so. This is a quick look, not a benchmark: run it again and every answer will differ. For measured results, see our benchmarks.
What we checked, by trying each answer ourselves: Shows all 12 products with the right prices and ratings; Brand, colour, size and price filters work; Sorting by price and by rating is correct; Adds no products, prices or claims that are not in the feed. A partial pass counts as half.
Most models got the hard part right. All but two of the pages show all twelve jackets with the right prices and ratings, and almost every filter and sort did what it should. The differences are in restraint and finish. Claude Opus 5.5 is the best page: every check passes, it has the fullest price filtering (min and max boxes plus bands), and of the first ten it is the only one that draws a trench, an anorak and a cape as different garments (2.5 minutes, $0.36). DeepSeek V4.1 Flash and GPT-6.1 Sol also pass everything; DeepSeek V4.1 Flash did it for $0.013 in 117 s, and Claude Haiku 5.5 and GPT-6 Luna, added on 8 October, for under a cent. DeepSeek V4.1 Flash 1017, added on 19 October, passes everything too, with its own shapes for the trench and the cape ($0.036). So does MiniMax M3.1 Flash, added the same day on OpenRouter's free route, though all its jackets share one shape, and so does Mercury 3, added the same day ($0.020). GPT-6.1 Terra, added on 27 October, passes everything for $0.026, with one hooded shape for most jackets. Kimi K3.1 Pro, added the same day, has every filter and sort right and draws each garment differently, but its intro promises insulated parkas ($0.24). Claude Fable 5.2, added on 10 November, passes everything as well, draws each garment differently and greys out filter options that would leave no jackets, but it took 5.7 minutes and cost $1.48, four times what Opus 5.5's page cost.
Gemini, Qwen and Mistral built working pages but added waterproof ratings and other specs that the feed never gives, which a real shop could not publish. Kimi K3's price filter matches nothing at all. Grok 4.7 only produced code on its fifth try, and that page crashes on load and shows no products.