The answers to “A newsletter email that works in email”, side by side

Playground · Business · HTML

A newsletter email that works in email

AI models write a monthly newsletter email for a UK sock maker. We check email safety, dark mode, and whether they make up business facts.

About this test

Email HTML follows older rules than the web. Layout goes in tables, styles go inline, there is no JavaScript and there are no remote images, and the result still has to hold up when a mail app switches to dark mode. The prompt asks for a Hollow & Pine newsletter with three items: the Moss colour back in stock, a short wool-washing guide, and 15% off with AUTUMN15 until 31 October. Look at whether the discount code stays legible in dark mode. Also look at what each model adds to the brief. Prices, fibre content, addresses and delivery terms all appear in emails that were given none of them, and a shop could not send those without checking every line.

Read more

The prompt, word for word

Write the HTML for a monthly newsletter email from Hollow & Pine, a small UK maker of merino socks. This month: the new "Moss" colour is back in stock, a short guide to washing wool, and 15% off with the code AUTUMN15 until 31 October.

It has to work as an email: table-based layout, inline styles, 600 px wide, no JavaScript, no external images (use coloured blocks or inline SVG instead), and readable in dark mode. Give one complete HTML file.
Show the whole prompt

Default settings: no thinking effort set, no temperature, and room for 64,000 tokens. A card says so when an answer was made with other settings: “limit 128k” means it could use up to 128,000.

Every answer runs live, in a sandboxed frame. Click into one to play with it.

How each model did

RankModelChecksTimeCost
1 GPT-6.1 Sol Our pick 4.5 of 5 53 s $0.030
2 GPT-6 Luna Best value 4.5 of 5 27 s $0.001
3 GPT-6.1 Terra 4.5 of 5 28 s $0.012
4 Kimi K3.1 Pro 4.5 of 5 8.1 min $0.170
5 Claude Opus 5.5 4.5 of 5 98 s $0.235
6 Claude Fable 5.2 4.5 of 5 2.7 min $0.689
7 Mercury 3 4 of 5 10 s $0.002
8 Claude Haiku 5.5 4 of 5 29 s $0.004
9 MiniMax M3.1 Flash (free route) 4 of 5 2.4 min $0.013
10 DeepSeek V4.1 Flash 4 of 5 50 s $0.018
11 DeepSeek V4.1 Flash 1017 4 of 5 88 s $0.029
12 Grok 4.7 4 of 5 42 s $0.030
13 Mistral Large 4 4 of 5 13 min $0.078
14 Gemini 4 Carbon 4 of 5 94 s $0.079
15 Kimi K3 4 of 5 2.9 min $0.159
16 Claude Fable 5.1 4 of 5 2.0 min $0.574
17 Gemini 3.8 Flash 3.5 of 5 45 s $0.028
18 Muse Spark 1.3 3.5 of 5 61 s $0.028
19 Qwen3.8 Max (0902) 3.5 of 5 13 min $0.182
20 Muse Ember Pending 15 s $0.004
21 Gemini 4 Argon Pending 33 s $0.050

Ranked by our pick, then checks passed, then cost. Time and cost count every try; each dot is one check, in the order listed below (filled: passed, half: partly, empty: failed). Click a model for its notes.

What each answer cost, against the checks it passed

Best value: GPT-6 Luna, 4.5 of 5 checks for $0.001. Our pick: GPT-6.1 Sol, 4.5 of 5 for $0.030. The best value is the cheapest answer with the most checks passed, counting every try.

0%20%40%60%80%100% $0.001$0.01$0.1$1 Cost, every try (log scale) Checks passed GPT-6.1 Sol GPT-6 Luna

Best valueOur pickOther answers

Notes on each answer

1

GPT-6.1 Sol

Our pick 4.5 of 5

A plain, correct build with a dark green header, a flat Moss colour block, the offer on a beige band and three care tips, all in tables with inline styles and no style block at all. It is the only one of the first ten answers that sticks to the brief's facts, and it leaves "[Insert business postal address, United Kingdom]" as a placeholder. Its weak spot is dark mode: there are no dark styles, so it stays a light email that is readable but left entirely to the mail app.

  • Stays readable in dark mode (partly)

53 s · 2,934 output tokens (254 thinking) · $0.030

2

GPT-6 Luna

4.5 of 5

A light, tidy email: a serif "A little warmth for autumn" header, a pale green Moss card with a "Shop Moss socks" button, a flat Moss swatch beside a three-sentence washing guide, and AUTUMN15 in a dashed box with "Offer ends 31 October", all in tables with inline styles and no style block. It sticks to the brief, with no prices, sizes, fibre blends, policies or address, though it calls Moss "much-loved", signs off "made in the UK" and links to a made-up hollowandpine.co.uk; unlike GPT-6.1 Sol's, it leaves no placeholder for a postal address. Like Sol's, it has no dark styles and declares itself light-only, so dark mode is left to the mail app. The cheapest and fastest of the first twelve answers, at $0.001 in 27 seconds.

  • Stays readable in dark mode (partly)

27 s · 2,969 output tokens (787 thinking) · $0.001

Added 8 October 2026.
3

GPT-6.1 Terra

4.5 of 5

A dark green header, a pale "Moss is back." panel, three numbered washing steps, a "Take 15% off" band with AUTUMN15 in a dashed box, and a short sign-off, all in tables with inline styles and no style block. Like GPT-6.1 Sol's, it keeps to the brief: no prices, policies or extra offers, and it says to check the care label rather than inventing a temperature. Also like Sol's, it has no dark styles, so it stays a light email that is readable but left to the mail app. It has no postal address line at all, where Sol leaves a placeholder. 28 seconds, $0.012.

  • Stays readable in dark mode (partly)

28 s · 2,439 output tokens (477 thinking) · $0.012

Added 27 October 2026.
4

Kimi K3.1 Pro

4.5 of 5

A serif "Moss has returned." hero in deep green, three numbered care steps, an offer panel and a full footer, neatly laid out. Its dark mode works: every panel and the code box change colour and all of it stays readable. The facts slip in small ways: "warm, breathable merino", washing "at 30°C or below" and "small-scale making" are not in the brief, though it adds no prices, policies, dates or address. The code, 15% and 31 October are all correct. 8.1 minutes, $0.17.

  • Invents no business facts the brief did not give: no prices, materials, addresses, delivery or returns policies, other offers or dates (partly)

8.1 min · 16,972 output tokens (12,596 thinking) · $0.170

Added 27 October 2026.
5

Claude Opus 5.5

4.5 of 5

A green "Moss is back." hero, a Moss swatch, four washing steps and AUTUMN15 on a brown band, and the dark mode is the most careful in the set, with the code box staying sharp. It uses placeholders for the address and adds no prices or terms. But it labels the swatch "Merino wool blend", a fibre claim the brief never made, and adds a sold-out story ("sold out in a few weeks").

  • Invents no business facts the brief did not give: no prices, materials, addresses, delivery or returns policies, other offers or dates (partly)

98 s · 11,735 output tokens (2,215 thinking) · $0.235

6

Claude Fable 5.2

4.5 of 5

The best-looking email on the page: a cream letter with a green sock built from coloured table cells (its reply says Gmail and Outlook strip inline SVG), "Moss" back in stock with a button, four numbered washing habits, and AUTUMN15 in a dashed box on a dark green band with 15% and 31 October. It is all tables and inline styles at 600 px, with no script and no images; one style block holds only the dark-mode and small-screen rules. Dark mode is complete: every panel, the button and the code box change and all of it stays readable. It adds no prices, policies, offer terms or address, and its reply says it left the address out for the shop to add, though the email has no placeholder for it. Where it goes past the brief is the washing guide, as Kimi K3.1 Pro's did: "Merino naturally resists odour" and a 30°C wash are claims about the product that the brief never made, softened by "When in doubt, follow the care label". 2.7 minutes and $0.69, the dearest of the first nineteen answers on this page.

  • Invents no business facts the brief did not give: no prices, materials, addresses, delivery or returns policies, other offers or dates (partly)

2.7 min · 17,191 output tokens (9,646 thinking) · $0.689

Added 10 November 2026.
7

Mercury 3

4 of 5

A light, tidy email: a cream header with a leaf drawn in SVG and "HOLLOW & PINE" in spaced capitals, a moss-green "New shade back in stock" block with a "Shop now" button, a four-step washing guide and AUTUMN15 in a dashed box with "Valid until 31 October", all in tables with inline styles at 600 px. Its dark styles keep every part readable. But it adds a "Signature merino blend · all sizes" line, a made-up hollowandpine.co.uk, and an address, "Shepton Mallet, Somerset, UK". 10 seconds, $0.0024.

  • Invents no business facts the brief did not give: no prices, materials, addresses, delivery or returns policies, other offers or dates

10 s · 6,938 output tokens (4,474 thinking) · $0.002

Added 19 October 2026.
8

Claude Haiku 5.5

4 of 5

A dark green "October letter" header, a flat Moss swatch, four numbered washing habits and AUTUMN15 in a dashed box, all in tables with inline styles. Dark mode is handled and the code stays clear, though the step numbers fade almost to nothing. It leaves the address as a placeholder but invents product facts ("Spun from 100% merino", "Mid-weight · Crew", "UK sizes 4 to 13", "made in small batches in the UK") and calls the offer "15% off everything". The cheapest and fastest of the first eleven answers, at $0.004 in 29 seconds.

  • Invents no business facts the brief did not give: no prices, materials, addresses, delivery or returns policies, other offers or dates

29 s · 7,517 output tokens (898 thinking) · $0.004

Added 8 October 2026.
9

MiniMax M3.1 Flash (free route)

4 of 5

A forest-green email: a "Moss is back." hero with a "Shop Moss" button and a Moss swatch, the AUTUMN15 offer and 31 October on a yellow band, a three-step washing guide and a "Why merino" panel, all in tables with inline styles at 600 px. Its dark mode keeps most of it readable, but the "Moss is back." headline and the panel's three headings turn dark green on dark green and all but vanish. It adds no prices, policies or address, but it does add claims the brief never made: "Small-batch merino socks from the UK" and merino that regulates temperature and resists odour. One try, 2.4 minutes on OpenRouter's free route, so the time is not representative; $0.013 at list prices.

  • Stays readable in dark mode (partly)
  • Invents no business facts the brief did not give: no prices, materials, addresses, delivery or returns policies, other offers or dates (partly)

2.4 min · 21,579 output tokens (15,049 thinking) · $0.013

Added 19 October 2026.
10

DeepSeek V4.1 Flash

4 of 5

Three tidy rounded cards for the restock, three washing steps and the offer, correct and fully adapted for dark mode. It invents "100% merino", "18.5 micron", "Knitted in Leicestershire" and "Sizes S–XL". It also adds "Not valid with other offers", "Free UK delivery on orders over £30" and an address at "12 Mill Lane, Hebden Bridge".

  • Invents no business facts the brief did not give: no prices, materials, addresses, delivery or returns policies, other offers or dates

50 s · 15,266 output tokens (10,121 thinking) · $0.018

11

DeepSeek V4.1 Flash 1017

4 of 5

A forest-green email: a Moss hero with a "Shop Moss" button, three colour blocks, four numbered washing steps and an offer box with the AUTUMN15 code and 31 October, all in tables with inline styles at 600 px, with a full dark mode that stays readable. It invents a lot: "100% merino", "spun in Yorkshire from non-mulesed fleece", a small mill in the Pennines, a reinforced heel, "Online only. One use per customer. Cannot be combined with other offers.", an address in Holmfirth and a named sender. 88 seconds, $0.029.

  • Invents no business facts the brief did not give: no prices, materials, addresses, delivery or returns policies, other offers or dates

88 s · 23,894 output tokens (17,418 thinking) · $0.029

Added 19 October 2026.
12

Grok 4.7

4 of 5

A quiet email written like a letter, with the Moss colourway in a bordered card, three care steps and AUTUMN15 on a dark chip, and dark mode handled well. It adds product and offer details: "Crew and ankle, sizes UK 2–12", an offer that "applies to full-price pairs", and "Prices in GBP". Those terms narrow the offer the brief described.

  • Invents no business facts the brief did not give: no prices, materials, addresses, delivery or returns policies, other offers or dates

42 s · 4,874 output tokens (113 thinking) · $0.030

Billed for 1,350 input tokens, about 1,205 more than the other models for the same prompt. We sent no system prompt, and the extra is there on every one of its requests, so it is text the provider adds itself.
13

Mistral Large 4

4 of 5

A drawn SVG sock beside "Moss is back.", four care tips in a grid and a rust offer band, with one of the best dark versions in the set. It invents more than any other answer: "£18 a pair", "100% merino wool", "Made in Devon", a Tiverton address and "Free UK delivery over £30 · 30-day returns". It also adds gift cards, "one use per customer" and a "September's sellout".

  • Invents no business facts the brief did not give: no prices, materials, addresses, delivery or returns policies, other offers or dates

13 min · 37,108 output tokens (26,518 thinking) · $0.078

14

Gemini 4 Carbon

4 of 5

A 600-pixel table email with a green sock illustration, a restock, wool-care guide and the right AUTUMN15 offer. It stayed readable with a dark colour scheme in Chromium; no mail-client compatibility suite was run. It invents 400 pairs in stock, Yorkshire dyeing, an address and free delivery over £45, among other unsupported business details. 1 try, 94 s, $0.0794.

  • Invents no business facts the brief did not give: no prices, materials, addresses, delivery or returns policies, other offers or dates

94 s · 7,910 output tokens (1,138 thinking) · $0.079

Added 11 November 2026.
15

Kimi K3

4 of 5

An olive "Moss is back." hero, a five-swatch "colour shelf", four washing steps and a rust offer band, all of which hold up in dark mode. It invents "100% merino", a stock promise ("gone until spring"), "One use per customer" and an address at "Unit 3, Stubbing Wharf Mill · Hebden Bridge". The header is dated "October 2025", a year the brief never gave.

  • Invents no business facts the brief did not give: no prices, materials, addresses, delivery or returns policies, other offers or dates

2.9 min · 11,343 output tokens (5,509 thinking) · $0.159

16

Claude Fable 5.1

4 of 5

The most fully written answer: "Colour No. 07 — Moss", five washing rules and a subscriber offer box, with dark mode handled throughout except a "Shop the range" button that loses its fill. Almost every business detail is made up: "78% extra-fine merino", "hand-linked in Yorkshire", "Sizes UK 4–13", "One use per customer. Can't be combined with other offers", and an address at "Unit 4, Beck Mill, Hebden Bridge". It is also the dearest of the first eighteen answers.

  • Invents no business facts the brief did not give: no prices, materials, addresses, delivery or returns policies, other offers or dates

2.0 min · 11,448 output tokens (1,426 thinking) · $0.574

17

Gemini 3.8 Flash

3.5 of 5

A neat card with a line-drawn sock, a dashed "October readers' gift" box and three wash tips whose SVG icons nearly vanish in dark mode. It invents a lot: "240 pairs off the vintage Bentley Komet needles in Derbyshire", "18.5-micron certified non-mulesed merino", an offer "valid on single pairs, three-packs, and gift boxes", and a Hope Valley address. It also dates the deadline "31 October 2024", a date that has already passed.

  • All three items, with the code AUTUMN15, 15% and 31 October correct (partly)
  • Invents no business facts the brief did not give: no prices, materials, addresses, delivery or returns policies, other offers or dates

45 s · 7,395 output tokens (1,418 thinking) · $0.028

18

Muse Spark 1.3

3.5 of 5

The busiest layout, with a dark hero holding an SVG pair of socks, a "Pairs well with" swatch row and three tip cards; in dark mode AUTUMN15 turns dark green on near-black and can barely be read. It invents a price and a shipping policy ("£16 a pair", "Free UK shipping over £30"). It also adds stock levels ("Charcoal: Low stock"), terms ("One per customer, can't be combined") and a Sheffield address.

  • Stays readable in dark mode (partly)
  • Invents no business facts the brief did not give: no prices, materials, addresses, delivery or returns policies, other offers or dates

61 s · 6,570 output tokens (1,554 thinking) · $0.028

19

Qwen3.8 Max (0902)

3.5 of 5

The most decorated answer, with a knitted-stitch SVG band and a "Wool School" box. Its style block adds CSS animations and hovers, and its step badges stretch into ovals that run into each other. It invents terms and a delivery policy ("Excludes gift cards · stacks with free UK delivery over £40", "One use per person"), plus a re-knitted heel and a Hebden Bridge address.

  • Email-safe build: tables, inline styles, no JavaScript, no external images (partly)
  • Invents no business facts the brief did not give: no prices, materials, addresses, delivery or returns policies, other offers or dates

13 min · 30,356 output tokens (20,203 thinking) · $0.182

20

Muse Ember

15 s · 8,167 output tokens (3,945 thinking) · $0.004

Added 9 November 2026.
21

Gemini 4 Argon

33 s · 4,979 output tokens · $0.050

Added 13 October 2026.

One answer per model, at each model's default settings unless the card says otherwise, through OpenRouter. If an answer ran out of room or stopped short, we asked again with more room, then with thinking off, and say so. This is a quick look, not a benchmark: run it again and every answer will differ. For measured results, see our benchmarks.

How we pick. Claude Opus 5.5 tried every answer (clicking, dragging and playing it in a browser), marked the checks and drafted the notes. Our pick is a judgement among the answers with the most checks passed, not a score: the checks show what works, the pick is which of those we would rather use. Opus is an Anthropic model, and Claude answers are our pick in 18 of 29 tests, so weigh Claude picks with that in mind. Our method calls for a blind second opinion from another lab's model on any Claude pick; none is recorded for this page yet.

What we checked, by trying each answer ourselves: Email-safe build: tables, inline styles, no JavaScript, no external images; 600 px wide; All three items, with the code AUTUMN15, 15% and 31 October correct; Stays readable in dark mode; Invents no business facts the brief did not give: no prices, materials, addresses, delivery or returns policies, other offers or dates. A partial pass counts as half.

Verdict

Every model follows the rules of email HTML, with a 600 px table, inline styles, no scripts and no remote images. All but one of the first ten also make up business facts the brief never gave: prices, fibre content, sizes, addresses, delivery and returns policies, and offer terms. GPT-6.1 Sol is the only one of those ten a shop could send as written. It uses only the brief's facts, leaves the address as a placeholder, and took 53 seconds at $0.030. Its one weakness is that it has no dark styles. Claude Opus 5.5 is the closest runner-up and has the best dark mode. Deleting its "Merino wool blend" label and its sold-out line would leave it clean. It took 98 seconds at $0.235.

The models that invent the most are Mistral Large 4 ("£18 a pair", "30-day returns"), Gemini 3.8 Flash ("240 pairs", "non-mulesed merino", and a "31 October 2024" deadline) and Claude Fable 5.1 ("78% extra-fine merino"), which at $0.574 was also the dearest of the first eighteen answers. Meta Muse Spark 1.3 adds a price and a shipping policy, and its discount code can barely be read in dark mode. DeepSeek V4.1 Flash 1017, added on 19 October, has a complete dark mode but invents a Yorkshire mill, non-mulesed fleece, offer terms and an address. MiniMax M3.1 Flash, added the same day on OpenRouter's free route, invents no prices, policies or address, but adds small-batch and merino-benefit claims, and its dark mode hides the headline. Mercury 3, added the same day, has a clean dark mode and took 10 seconds, but invents a Somerset address and a merino-blend line. GPT-6.1 Terra, added on 27 October, keeps to the brief as Sol does and also has no dark styles, for $0.012 in 28 seconds; Sol stays our pick because it leaves a place for the postal address. Kimi K3.1 Pro, added the same day, has a full dark mode but adds merino-benefit claims, at $0.17. Claude Fable 5.2, added on 10 November, comes closest to having both: a complete dark mode, a sock drawn in table cells, and no prices, policies or address. Its washing guide does say merino resists odour and gives a 30°C wash, which the brief did not, so Sol, which adds nothing, stays our pick; Fable 5.2 cost $0.69.

What would your prompt get?The Spring Prompt playground runs one prompt on several models at once, from OpenAI, Anthropic, Google, Mistral and others, side by side.
Ask for access
More from the playground
All tests →
Export
Include

Chrome will ask to share this tab: choose Allow. Only the board below is recorded.

Spring Promptspringprompt.com