Ranked by our pick, then checks passed, then cost. Time and cost count every try; each dot is one check, in the order listed below (filled: passed, half: partly, empty: failed). Click a model for its notes.
A cream cake on a gold board, seen from above. A palette knife first combs the top into fine rings, then a star nozzle pipes a pink shell border round the edge, ten two-tone rosettes in pink and caramel, and "Happy Birthday" in chocolate script, stroke by stroke, in about half a minute. The shells and rosettes have nozzle ridges, the lettering is a raised rope of icing and the easiest to read on this page, and the light swings right across the cake with the pointer, throwing the shadow of the border the other way. It holds and starts again on a click. Its first try, at its default thinking, used all 128,000 tokens it can write and sent nothing; the second, at low thinking, finished. The two tries took 33 minutes and cost $7.39, the dearest of the first ten answers on this page.
9.6 min · 56,650 output tokens (43,068 thinking) · $2.267 for this answer; 33 min and $7.388 over 2 tries
Took 2 tries: ran out of room at 128,000 tokens; finished at 128,000 tokens, low thinking.Added 10 November 2026.
A cream cake with a comb-marked top on a silver board. The bag pipes a shell border, rosettes and then "Happy Birthday" stroke by stroke in about 20 seconds. Shells and rosettes have visible nozzle ridges, the lettering is large and easy to read, and the light sweeps clearly across the icing with the pointer. It holds and starts again on a click. The piping has less body than Opus's. 20 minutes, $0.46.
20 min · 45,923 output tokens (33,150 thinking) · $0.460
Added 27 October 2026.
A white cake on a cake board on a wooden table. A shell border is piped round the edge, then rosettes in pink and lilac, then "Happy Birthday" in raised pink script. The ridges in the shells and rosettes read as buttercream, and the light rakes across them as you move the pointer. 4.4 minutes, $0.52.
4.4 min · 25,884 output tokens (17,409 thinking) · $0.518
A cream cake from above on a pale board. A piping bag works in the right order, border, eight rosettes, then "Happy Birthday" in raised pink script that is easy to read, all in about 20 seconds; it holds and starts again on a click. The border is a row of separate flat beads, the rosettes are small flat spirals, and no nozzle ridges show. The light moves, but gently. 58 seconds, $0.026.
- ◐ The buttercream looks piped, with ridges from the nozzle (partly)
58 s · 5,131 output tokens (1,034 thinking) · $0.026
Added 27 October 2026.
A cream cake seen from above, decorated in about 16 seconds: a double row of pearl beads round the edge, ten pink rosettes that spiral like snail shells, then "Happy Birthday" in bold blue italic letters with a dark edge. It holds and starts again on a click. The order is right, the writing is easy to read, and the light moves across the icing with the pointer, though with the pointer in the middle it burns out the centre of the cake. But the border is beads rather than shells, and the lettering looks typeset rather than piped. 2.9 minutes, $0.028.
- ◐ The buttercream looks piped, with ridges from the nozzle (partly)
2.9 min · 80,920 output tokens (75,283 thinking) · $0.028
Added 19 October 2026.
A cream cake from above on a silver board: a nozzle pipes a border of teardrop shells, then twelve swirled rosettes, then "Happy Birthday" in brown single-stroke lettering, finished in about 15 seconds; it holds and pipes again on a click. The order is right, the writing is clear, and the light moves strongly across the icing with the pointer. But the shells and rosettes are flat shapes with lines drawn on rather than ridged buttercream, so they look more like biscuits than piping. One try, 7.0 minutes on OpenRouter's free route, so the time is not representative; $0.031 at list prices.
- ◐ The buttercream looks piped, with ridges from the nozzle (partly)
7.0 min · 51,805 output tokens (40,729 thinking) · $0.031
Added 19 October 2026.
7
Muse Wonder Full
3 of 4
Made in Muse Code, not over the API: Full could screenshot its own work and fix it, and took 2 rounds. Elegant and in a sensible order: a crumb coat spread first, then the shell border, rosettes and the writing. But it is white on white, so the shells and rosettes barely show against the cake, and all the colour is in the pink lettering, which looks slightly doubled. The light catches the shells a little.
- ◐ The buttercream looks piped, with ridges from the nozzle (partly)
- ◐ The light follows the pointer across the icing (partly)
–
A cream cake seen from above on a grey board, finished in about eight seconds: a border of smooth pink pearls, eight pink rosettes, then "Happy Birthday" in pink script. The order is right, and the highlights and the lettering's shadow move with the pointer, but the border is beads rather than shells, the rosettes are flat discs with a faint swirl, and the small, doubled lettering is hard to read. 2.1 minutes, $0.042.
- ◐ The buttercream looks piped, with ridges from the nozzle (partly)
- ◐ "Happy Birthday" is written in icing and easy to read (partly)
2.1 min · 34,608 output tokens (29,174 thinking) · $0.042
Added 19 October 2026.
A cream cake on a plate with a border of pink shells, pink rosettes, "Happy Birthday" in pink script and scattered sprinkles. Cheerful, but the icing is flat colour with little body, and the light changes little. Our first two requests were refused before it wrote anything (by our account's credit limit, then over a thinking setting this endpoint does not take); the third finished, and a duplicate request from our script asked once more, which is the answer shown. The two answers took 2.6 minutes and cost $0.44.
- ◐ The buttercream looks piped, with ridges from the nozzle (partly)
- ◐ The light follows the pointer across the icing (partly)
86 s · 10,469 output tokens (2,424 thinking) · $0.210 for this answer; 2.6 min and $0.436 over 4 tries
Took 4 tries: failed at 943,718 tokens; failed at 943,718 tokens, low thinking; finished at 128,000 tokens; finished at 128,000 tokens.
57 s · 32,422 output tokens (24,796 thinking) · $0.016
Added 9 November 2026.
91 s · 13,211 output tokens · $0.132
A black canvas in Chromium throughout the animation. Its fragment shader fails to compile because it adds a two-component vector to a three-component vector, so no cake, piping, writing or light response appears. The code judge passed it, but the browser did not render it. The client call took 20.1 minutes end to end; the saved reply reports 11.3 minutes. 1 try, 11 min, $0.5173.
Failed every check.
11 min · 51,700 output tokens (29,299 thinking) · $0.517
Added 11 November 2026.
One answer per model, at each model's default settings unless the card says otherwise, through OpenRouter. If an answer ran out of room or stopped short, we asked again with more room, then with thinking off, and say so. This is a quick look, not a benchmark: run it again and every answer will differ. For measured results, see our benchmarks.
What we checked, by trying each answer ourselves: Pipes in a believable order: border, rosettes and the writing; The buttercream looks piped, with ridges from the nozzle; "Happy Birthday" is written in icing and easy to read; The light follows the pointer across the icing. A partial pass counts as half.
Claude Fable 5.2, added on 10 November, is our pick: a ridged shell border, two-tone rosettes and "Happy Birthday" in chocolate script that is the easiest to read here, with light that swings across the whole cake. It needed a second try at low thinking, and is the dearest of the first ten answers by far. Claude Opus 5.5's cake, our pick until then, also looks piped: shells and rosettes with body and ridges, raised pink lettering, and light that rakes across them, but its "Birthday" runs together. Muse Wonder's pink cake is the most fun but flat. Muse Wonder Full, after two rounds in Muse Code, makes the most careful process, starting with a crumb coat, but its pale icing disappears into the cake. DeepSeek V4.1 Flash 1017, added on 19 October, pipes in the right order in seconds, but its border is smooth beads and its lettering is hard to read. MiniMax M3.1 Flash, added the same day on OpenRouter's free route, pipes in the right order with clear lettering, but its shells and rosettes are flat. Mercury 3, added the same day, pipes in the right order with clear lettering, but its border is beads and its writing looks printed. GPT-6.1 Terra, added on 27 October, pipes in order with clear script, but its border is flat beads and its rosettes are flat spirals. Kimi K3.1 Pro, added the same day, comes closest to Opus: ridged shells and rosettes, large clear lettering and light that sweeps the icing, though the piping has less body.