Ranked by our pick, then checks passed, then cost. Time and cost count every try; each dot is one check, in the order listed below (filled: passed, half: partly, empty: failed). Click a model for its notes.
A white cup on a saucer, seen from above, with a crema of swirled browns and a bright ring at the rim. A steel jug tips in and the milk lands as a white disc, then five more are pushed in behind it, and a pull-through from the top draws each into a heart: a tulip of five stacked petals under a small heart, centred and filling the cup. The cup, saucer and crema are the most real on this page with a tulip in them, and moving the pointer swings the light and the cup's shadow right round. It holds and pours again on a click. The stream from the jug is short, and there is no stem below the last petal. Its first try, at its default thinking, used all 128,000 tokens it can write and sent nothing; the second, at low thinking, finished. The two tries took 29 minutes and cost $6.10, the dearest of the first ten answers on this page.
4.7 min · 24,331 output tokens (17,072 thinking) · $0.974 for this answer; 29 min and $6.096 over 2 tries
Took 2 tries: ran out of room at 128,000 tokens; finished at 128,000 tokens, low thinking.Added 10 November 2026.
2
Muse Wonder Full
3.5 of 4
Made in Muse Code, not over the API: Full could screenshot its own work and fix it, and took 3 rounds. The only tulip of the first six answers: the espresso settles, the milk builds a base, five petals are pushed in one after another, and a pull-through cuts the stack, leaving a small heart on top. It is small in the cup and still close to a leaf if you are strict, and the crema is dotted with large spots, so the cup looks less real than Opus's. The light glints across the surface. Its fixes made the hearts rounder and wider apart so that it read as a tulip.
- ◐ The crema and the cup look real (partly)
–
A cup from above and a steel jug that pours a thin stream: a base heart, then hearts pushed up one after another, and a pull-through from top to tail. The finished tulip has four clear tiers and a fine stem and fills the cup well, the cleanest pattern on this page until Claude Fable 5.2's. The light moves over the surface and the cup. The cup is neat but illustrated, and the crema is a smooth, even brown rather than foam. It holds and pours again on a click. 72 seconds, $0.032.
- ◐ The crema and the cup look real (partly)
72 s · 6,454 output tokens (1,017 thinking) · $0.032
Added 27 October 2026.
A jug swings in over a cup on a saucer and pours a growing white mass, then a small heart and a thin pull-through. The cup and the swirled crema look real, and the light moves across them. The pattern does not convince: wide tiers with a heart on top and a short stem, more a fir tree than a tulip. It holds and pours again on a click. 19 minutes, $0.41.
- ◐ The finished pattern is a tulip: stacked petals with a pull-through (partly)
19 min · 40,731 output tokens (29,138 thinking) · $0.408
Added 27 October 2026.
A white cup from above with a dark crema and a silver jug that tips in and pours a thin stream, finished in about ten seconds; it holds and pours again on a click. The pattern is a small outline: two nested curved petals with a line pulled through and a short stem, more like a pale onion than a tulip's stacked, filled petals. The crema is a smooth gradient and the cup is plain, and the highlight on the rim and the coffee moves with the pointer. One try, 8.7 minutes on OpenRouter's free route, so the time is not representative; $0.025 at list prices.
- ◐ The finished pattern is a tulip: stacked petals with a pull-through (partly)
- ◐ The crema and the cup look real (partly)
8.7 min · 41,759 output tokens (29,628 thinking) · $0.025
Added 19 October 2026.
A cup and saucer on a wooden table, with a white stream laying stacked petals and a central pull-through into pale coffee. The pouring vessel looks like a round ladle rather than a milk jug, and the thick raised white petals look more like relief icing than milk mixed into crema. The surface catches a strong moving light. It holds the finished pattern and starts pouring again on a click. 1 try, 4.0 min, $0.2056.
- ◐ Shows the pour from the jug, with the milk landing in the espresso (partly)
- ◐ The crema and the cup look real (partly)
4.0 min · 20,533 output tokens · $0.206
Added 11 November 2026.
The most realistic cup: a white cup and saucer on dark wood, a crema with real texture, and a steel jug pouring from below. But the milk lands as a lumpy white column with jagged edges, not a tulip, and it sits flat on the crema. The light moves across the cup rim and the crema. 6.6 minutes, $0.78.
- ✗ The finished pattern is a tulip: stacked petals with a pull-through
6.6 min · 39,176 output tokens (26,407 thinking) · $0.784
A white cup seen from above with a smooth brown crema. There is no jug: the milk is a bright dot landing near the rim, and the pattern grows in about four seconds. It ends on four stacked cream arcs with a pull-through and a stem, the right structure for a tulip, but flat and opaque, so it looks more like a cartoon fir tree than milk foam. The highlight moves across the crema and the rim with the pointer. 2.3 minutes, $0.045.
- ◐ Shows the pour from the jug, with the milk landing in the espresso (partly)
- ◐ The finished pattern is a tulip: stacked petals with a pull-through (partly)
- ◐ The crema and the cup look real (partly)
2.3 min · 37,676 output tokens (31,100 thinking) · $0.045
Added 19 October 2026.
Titled "Tulip", with steam rising and the jug pouring from above, but it pours a large leaf, a rosetta with a centre line and nested chevrons. Clean and pretty, and the wrong pattern. Our first two requests were refused before it wrote anything (by our account's credit limit at its listed 943,718 tokens of room, then over a thinking setting this endpoint does not take); the third, with 128,000 tokens, is the answer. 1.1 minutes, $0.18.
- ✗ The finished pattern is a tulip: stacked petals with a pull-through
- ◐ The crema and the cup look real (partly)
- ◐ The light follows the pointer across the surface (partly)
67 s · 8,868 output tokens (3,274 thinking) · $0.178 for this answer; 67 s and $0.178 over 3 tries
Took 3 tries: failed at 943,718 tokens; failed at 943,718 tokens, low thinking; finished at 128,000 tokens.
A dark cup seen at a low angle, with a small cream cloud on a stalk, like a tree or a mushroom, in the middle of the coffee, finished within a few seconds. There is no jug and no pour, the pattern is not a tulip, the cup is a thin ring with a flat brown surface and a faint grey box behind the pattern, and moving the pointer barely changes the light. Two tries: the first stopped unfinished after five minutes, and the second, with thinking off, took 9 seconds. 5.2 minutes and $0.0023 in all.
Missed or only partly met 4 of the 4 checks.
9 s · 4,712 output tokens · $0.002 for this answer; 5.2 min and $0.002 over 2 tries
Took 2 tries: stopped mid-page at 131,072 tokens; finished at 131,072 tokens, thinking off.Added 19 October 2026.
79 s · 45,533 output tokens (35,942 thinking) · $0.023
Added 9 November 2026.
89 s · 13,463 output tokens · $0.135
One answer per model, at each model's default settings unless the card says otherwise, through OpenRouter. If an answer ran out of room or stopped short, we asked again with more room, then with thinking off, and say so. This is a quick look, not a benchmark: run it again and every answer will differ. For measured results, see our benchmarks.
What we checked, by trying each answer ourselves: Shows the pour from the jug, with the milk landing in the espresso; The finished pattern is a tulip: stacked petals with a pull-through; The crema and the cup look real; The light follows the pointer across the surface. A partial pass counts as half.
Claude Fable 5.2, added on 10 November, is our pick: the first answer to pass every check, with a tulip of five stacked petals and a heart, poured from a jug into a cup and crema that look real. It needed a second try at low thinking, and is the dearest of the first ten answers by far. GPT-6.1 Terra, added on 27 October, was our pick until then: it pours a clear tulip, four stacked hearts with a clean pull-through, from a jug, in one try, in 72 seconds for $0.032, though its crema is flat. Muse Wonder Full was our pick before that and made the only tulip of the first six answers, stacked petals with a pull-through, in three rounds in Muse Code, where it looked at its own page and reshaped the hearts; its tulip is smaller and its crema is spotted. Claude Opus 5.5 has by far the most realistic cup and crema, but its milk lands as a lumpy blob, and Muse Wonder poured a leaf. DeepSeek V4.1 Flash 1017, added on 19 October, comes closer than Opus: stacked arcs with a pull-through, but flat, and poured with no jug. MiniMax M3.1 Flash, added the same day on OpenRouter's free route, pours from a jug, but its pattern is a small outline rather than a tulip. Mercury 3, added the same day, needed two tries and ends on a small cream cloud on a stalk, with no jug. Kimi K3.1 Pro, added on 27 October, has a realistic cup and a real pour, but its wide tiers look more like a fir tree than a tulip.