Ranked by our pick, then checks passed, then cost. Time and cost count every try; each dot is one check, in the order listed below (filled: passed, half: partly, empty: failed). Click a model for its notes.
A canvas toned in warm ochre. It sketches the plate and lemon in charcoal, blocks in a dark background and a table in broad strokes, lays the blue plate in curved strokes that follow its rim, builds the lemon in short yellow dabs with a cool shadow and a thick white highlight, and signs the corner. The whole canvas is covered, the strokes are separate and ridged, and the ridges light up and fall into shadow as the pointer moves the light. It reads at once as a lemon on a blue plate. It holds and starts again on a click. It takes about 40 seconds to paint. One try, 19 minutes and $4.65, the dearest of the first ten answers on this page.
19 min · 116,230 output tokens (93,315 thinking) · $4.650
Added 10 November 2026.
Short strokes lay in a green and brown ground, then a swirling blue plate, then a lemon in a mass of small yellow dabs, in about 20 seconds. Brush marks show everywhere and a patch of highlights moves over the fruit with the pointer. The lemon is ragged at the edges, more like a ball of straw than a smooth fruit, and the even dashes of the background look like a pattern. It holds and starts again on a click. 71 seconds, $0.032.
71 s · 6,363 output tokens (1,859 thinking) · $0.032
Added 27 October 2026.
Paints the whole canvas: horizontal dabs of grey-green, mauve and olive, then the table, a blue plate in circular strokes and a yellow lemon with white highlights, finished in about 20 seconds; it holds and paints again on a click. A raised, crinkled paint texture covers the whole canvas, and its ridges light up differently as the pointer moves. The background reads as camouflage, and the lemon is a rounded oval without pointed ends. 3.0 minutes, $0.058.
3.0 min · 48,265 output tokens (40,700 thinking) · $0.058
Added 19 October 2026.
A canvas sketch is filled stroke by stroke: dark background, light tabletop and blue plate first, then a yellow lemon and its highlights. Thick crosshatched strokes and visible canvas weave catch the moving light. The lemon and plate read clearly. It holds the completed painting, and a click starts it again. 1 try, 9.4 min, $0.4424.
9.4 min · 44,214 output tokens (18,970 thinking) · $0.442
Added 11 November 2026.
It starts on a bare panel, blocks in a dark background and table, lays a deep blue plate with rim strokes, then a lemon with pointed ends and a cast shadow. A clear, well composed picture, with strokes that follow the form and ridges that catch the moving light, though the paint looks thinner than Opus's. It holds and starts again on a click. 23 minutes, $0.45.
23 min · 44,861 output tokens (33,277 thinking) · $0.449
Added 27 October 2026.
Paints the whole canvas stroke by stroke: a warm ground, a grey-green background in crossing strokes, brown table strokes, a plate in swirls of blue, then the lemon in layered yellow impasto. The ridges catch the light and shift as you move the pointer. The background is busy, but it was the first here that looked like oil paint. 7.2 minutes, $0.90.
7.2 min · 44,809 output tokens (31,790 thinking) · $0.897
A beige canvas painted in long, leaf-shaped strokes of green, grey and mauve, then a large blue oval plate, then a yellow lemon with a green leaf, finished in about 20 seconds; it holds and paints again on a click. The order is right and the lemon reads clearly, with a thick, flecked texture, but the plate is a smooth gradient with blue blobs dabbed on, and moving the pointer only shifts the shading a little. The background strokes look like palm fronds rather than a wall or a table. One try, 6.9 minutes on OpenRouter's free route, so the time is not representative; $0.031 at list prices.
- ◐ Thick paint and brush marks show, and the ridges catch the light as the pointer moves (partly)
6.9 min · 51,549 output tokens (36,996 thinking) · $0.031
Added 19 October 2026.
8
Muse Wonder Full
3 of 4
Made in Muse Code, not over the API: Full could screenshot its own work and fix it, and took 3 rounds. A framed canvas painted in a sensible order: the background blocked in with short horizontal dashes, the plate laid in, the lemon stroke by stroke, then the leaf and highlights last. But the lemon is small and breaks up into scattered yellow dashes on a nest of blue strokes, and the ridges barely change as the light moves.
- ◐ Thick paint and brush marks show, and the ridges catch the light as the pointer moves (partly)
- ◐ The finished picture clearly reads as a lemon on a blue plate (partly)
–
A cream background and a table edge are scratched in first, then a blue oval plate that fills most of the frame, then a large yellow-orange fruit with a green stalk and leaf, finished in about 16 seconds; it holds and starts again on a click. The order is right, and the cross-hatched scratches and the highlights shift as the pointer moves, but the marks look like pencil hatching rather than thick paint, the fruit is round, with no lemon tips, so it reads as an orange or a yolk, and with the pointer in the middle a white glare covers the fruit. 3.8 minutes, $0.034.
- ◐ Thick paint and brush marks show, and the ridges catch the light as the pointer moves (partly)
- ◐ The finished picture clearly reads as a lemon on a blue plate (partly)
3.8 min · 96,332 output tokens (87,294 thinking) · $0.034
Added 19 October 2026.
A dark streaked background, a wooden table, a blue plate with white rings and a glossy lemon with a long green leaf, mostly in place within eight seconds. The pointer drags a large glare across the plate. It looks like a rendered 3D lemon with a paint texture laid over it rather than an oil painting. Our first two requests were refused before it wrote anything (by our account's credit limit at its listed 943,718 tokens of room, then over a thinking setting this endpoint does not take); the third, with 128,000 tokens, is the answer. 2.6 minutes, $0.30.
- ◐ Paints in a real order: background and plate first, then the lemon, stroke by stroke (partly)
- ◐ Thick paint and brush marks show, and the ridges catch the light as the pointer moves (partly)
2.6 min · 14,958 output tokens (6,067 thinking) · $0.300 for this answer; 2.6 min and $0.300 over 3 tries
Took 3 tries: failed at 943,718 tokens; failed at 943,718 tokens, low thinking; finished at 128,000 tokens.
73 s · 44,180 output tokens (33,544 thinking) · $0.022
Added 9 November 2026.
73 s · 10,319 output tokens · $0.103
One answer per model, at each model's default settings unless the card says otherwise, through OpenRouter. If an answer ran out of room or stopped short, we asked again with more room, then with thinking off, and say so. This is a quick look, not a benchmark: run it again and every answer will differ. For measured results, see our benchmarks.
What we checked, by trying each answer ourselves: Paints in a real order: background and plate first, then the lemon, stroke by stroke; Thick paint and brush marks show, and the ridges catch the light as the pointer moves; The finished picture clearly reads as a lemon on a blue plate; Finishes, holds on the finished piece, and starts again on a click. A partial pass counts as half.
Claude Fable 5.2, added on 10 November, is our pick: an underdrawing, then a whole canvas of separate, ridged strokes that catch the light, and a lemon and plate that read at once. It is the dearest of the first ten answers by far. Claude Opus 5.5's lemon, our pick until then, also has convincing impasto: layered strokes with ridges that catch the light as you move the pointer, on a plate painted in swirls of blue. Its background is busy and patches of canvas are left bare. Muse Wonder's picture is cleaner but looks rendered rather than painted, and Muse Wonder Full, after three rounds in Muse Code, paints in the right order but ends on a small, scrambled lemon. DeepSeek V4.1 Flash 1017, added on 19 October, also passes every check, with a clearer lemon and plate than Opus, but its texture is an even crinkle over everything rather than separate brush strokes. MiniMax M3.1 Flash, added the same day on OpenRouter's free route, paints a clear lemon in the right order, but only the lemon looks thickly painted. Mercury 3, added the same day, paints in the right order, but its round fruit reads as an orange and its texture as hatching. GPT-6.1 Terra, added on 27 October, paints in order with strokes everywhere, but its lemon looks like a ball of straw. Kimi K3.1 Pro, added the same day, makes a clear, well composed picture of a proper lemon, with thinner paint than Opus.