Ranked by our pick, then checks passed, then cost. Time and cost count every try; each dot is one check, in the order listed below (filled: passed, half: partly, empty: failed). Click a model for its notes.
Three pale pearlescent cards on a deep green page ("For the quietly curious"): Mossmallow, a leaf-eared bunny, Dewdrifter, a snail with a raindrop shell, and Petalpip. The foil is a soft sheen that turns from butter yellow to lilac as the card tilts (about 12 degrees each way), rather than a loud rainbow, and the line drawings and serif type stay crisp under it. Left alone it sways only a few degrees. The back is a dark foil card with a sprout emblem ("Collected, not captured"). The most finished design here, in about three minutes for $0.12.
3.2 min · 11,927 output tokens (1,034 thinking) · $0.120
Dark glassy cards with a teal, purple and gold foil and a dotted grid, stacked as a fan (Petalwisp, a winged seed; Mossback Nib, a beetle; Sunmoth). It tilts, drifts and swipes well; the creatures are pale on dark and the small text is faint, and the back is a ring around the card number. A good answer for under a cent ($0.009), but it took eight minutes.
8.4 min · 49,278 output tokens (28,016 thinking) · $0.009
Glassy violet cards (Thimblewisp, a moth on a tulip; Sproutback Tortle; Larkhollow Fawnkin) with a rainbow band that sweeps across as the card tilts, and a striking back: a rainbow crosshatch around a sprout medallion. The drawings are simpler than the best here, but every part of the brief works, with numbered tabs and a Flip button as well as a tap. $0.025: only DeepSeek V4.1 Flash passed every check for less.
3.5 min · 50,038 output tokens (35,210 thinking) · $0.025
"Spring Prompt: First Editions": three glassy purple-to-teal cards in a carousel, with the neighbours angled at the sides: Spriglet, a green bean with a sprout, Puddlekin, a raindrop, and Wispbloom, a smiling pink flower, each with a serif name, an italic flavour line and its number. The card in view tilts up to 12 degrees towards the pointer while the foil colours turn and the glare follows, and two and a half seconds after the pointer stops it sways on its own. A click flips it to a dark back with a numbered medallion and a barcode, and arrows, dots, arrow keys and swipes move between the cards. The creatures are simple, emoji-like shapes and the foil is a soft wash rather than a rainbow. 4.0 minutes, $0.032.
4.0 min · 92,554 output tokens (83,078 thinking) · $0.032
Added 19 October 2026.
The most game-like set: bright white cards with HP badges, element tags ("Leaf", "Mist"), rarity and rainbow foil edges, with Bloombit, Dewdrake and Pollenpuff drawn as round SVG characters. The tilt and foil work well; the back is a smaller affair, a dark card with an "SP" badge and the creature's description. Cheerful rather than premium. $0.05 in under three minutes.
2.7 min · 11,811 output tokens (3,021 thinking) · $0.050
"The Little Wild": pale pastel cards under the title, with Mosslet, a sprout with a dewdrop, Pipflutter, a blushing moth, and Bumblebud, a round bee, each drawn inside an arch with a serif name, a quoted line and its number. The card leans about 7 degrees towards the pointer and sways a couple of degrees when left alone, and the foil is a soft wash that shifts between green, pink and gold, so it stays readable but is quieter than a rainbow. A click or tap turns it to a dark green back with a sprout emblem; arrows, dots and the arrow keys move between cards. It adds a collection name and the year 2025 that nobody asked for. 113 seconds, $0.051.
113 s · 10,160 output tokens (705 thinking) · $0.051
Added 27 October 2026.
"First Editions": a fan of three dark glass cards (Petalfin, a petal-crowned blob; Dewmoth, a moth; Mossling, a sprout) under a strong purple, red and green foil with a glare that moves. The card in view tilts up to about 13 degrees towards the pointer, drifts on its own after a few seconds, flips on a click, tap or Space to a back with an "SP" emblem and its number, and arrows, dots, keys and swipes move between the cards. The creatures are clear and the serif type is readable, though the flavour text is small. 3.6 minutes, $0.074.
3.6 min · 61,557 output tokens (50,026 thinking) · $0.074
Added 19 October 2026.
Pastel holo cards with a "1st edition" stamp (Pokko, a moss sprout; Lumoth, a lantern moth; Ripple, a water spirit), named tabs below and a dark back with a gold "Spring Prompt" seal. The foil shifts from lilac to lime and the art is sweet, but the tilt is small (about 5 degrees), and a card you flipped stays flipped when you come back to it. It ran out of room at 64,000 tokens; the second try, with 128,000, finished. The two tries took 35 minutes and cost $0.32.
17 min · 87,331 output tokens (56,041 thinking) · $0.183 for this answer; 35 min and $0.317 over 2 tries
Took 2 tries: ran out of room at 64,000 tokens; finished at 128,000 tokens.
Cream cards with gold frames (Bloomwhisk, a sprout bunny; Dewsprite, a raindrop; Petalflare), tidy and readable, with a back of concentric rings around a painted egg. The sheen is a single hard-edged diagonal band that slides across rather than a foil, so it reads as a glass reflection. It ran out of room at 64,000 tokens; the second try, with 128,000, finished. The two tries took 24 minutes and cost $0.41.
6.1 min · 31,332 output tokens (17,633 thinking) · $0.408 for this answer; 24 min and $0.408 over 2 tries
Took 2 tries: stopped mid-page at 64,000 tokens; finished at 128,000 tokens.
A dark "field archive": small framed cards with Budwhisker, a leaf-eared bunny, Puddleglim, an axolotl, and Wishwhick, a lion cub with a dandelion, finely drawn, with a name, a line of flavour text and 01/03 at the foot. The card tilts about 7 degrees, the foil runs across the frame in gold, green and violet, and left alone it sways up to 3 degrees. A click or tap flips it to a designed back with a rosette, habitat and nature lines and a serial; numbered tabs, arrows, arrow keys and swipes change the card. The foil is restrained and the small mono text is faint. 19 minutes, $0.42.
19 min · 42,132 output tokens (22,106 thinking) · $0.422
Added 27 October 2026.
The closest to a real trading card: a carousel of three framed cards (Mossbun, Petalmoth, Puddlewhisk) with name bars, a type line ("Meadow sprite, HT 7 cm, WT 40 g") and flavour text. The frame changes colour as it tilts, from blue to green to red, and a sparkle layer runs over it; the back is a navy card with an engraved seal. The glare is strong enough to wash out the creature in the middle of the card. $1.04 and eight minutes.
8.2 min · 51,727 output tokens (31,185 thinking) · $1.036
The loudest foil: a rainbow diamond pattern over the whole card that swings from green to magenta to gold as it tilts, with Mossling, a sprout blob, in front and two cards waiting either side. The creatures are cute and the back has a quiet sprout seal. It is more glitter than shine, and at $2.87 and 11 minutes the dearest of the first eighteen answers by far.
11 min · 57,380 output tokens (39,626 thinking) · $2.872
Three dark cards fanned on a deep green page with petals falling behind: Sprigget, a sprout-headed blob, Petalune, a blossom moth, and Dewkin, a dewdrop newt, each drawn in full colour with a habitat line, flavour text and its number. The card in front leans about seven degrees towards the pointer, and a strong rainbow foil and glare sweep across it as it does, turning the green card through gold to red. Left alone it sways and the foil keeps moving. A click turns it to a navy back with a guilloche rosette, a sprout emblem and the card's number, and arrows, numbered dots and the arrow keys move round the set. The names and text stay readable under the foil, though at the far tilt the colour is heavy over the art. A richer, louder set than GPT-6.1 Sol's pale one. 15 minutes and $3.78, the dearest of the first nineteen answers on this page.
15 min · 94,457 output tokens (69,275 thinking) · $3.781
Added 10 November 2026.
Muted olive cards from "Fieldnotes of the Fae": Mossling, a sprout with a heart, and Pipkin, who carries a lantern. Nicely drawn and set in a calm serif, and the card tilts and sways, but the foil is so faint that it barely reads as holographic. The back is a short written note. The fastest and cheapest answer, at $0.004 in 49 seconds.
- ◐ Tilts towards the pointer, with foil and glare that move with it (partly)
49 s · 7,871 output tokens (313 thinking) · $0.004
"Spring Prompt: First Editions": three cream cards (Pebblepip, a moss-hare holding a sunrise pebble; Mallowfin, a winged fish; Thimblewing, a bell bat) with clear drawings, numbers and flavour text, arrows, tabs and swipes to move between them, and dark backs with a glowing number, a short story and a barcode. The card tilts towards the pointer with a shifting shadow, drifts on its own when left alone and flips on a click. But the rainbow foil and glare are blended so softly into the pale fronts that they barely show; only the dark backs look holographic. One try, 5.8 minutes on OpenRouter's free route, so the time is not representative; $0.028 at list prices.
- ◐ Tilts towards the pointer, with foil and glare that move with it (partly)
5.8 min · 46,789 output tokens (29,165 thinking) · $0.028
Added 19 October 2026.
Dark cards with small creatures (Vernisprout, a dew gecko; Bloomveil, a squirrel) and the widest swing here, around 20 degrees when left alone. The foil is drawn as hard-edged blocks of gold, teal and purple that cut across the card and the text as it moves, so it looks broken rather than shiny. The back is a green foil card with a star seal. 96 seconds, $0.06.
- ◐ The creatures are drawn and the card text is readable (partly)
96 s · 16,338 output tokens (2,503 thinking) · $0.061
An elegant idea, "A collector's folio" of three plates (Vellum Moth, Brookglass Newt, Firstbud Hare) in pastel pearl foil. But the foil is so pale and opaque that the names and flavour text are hard to read, the tilt is small (about 5 degrees), and on a phone the card covers the title. Its first try thought for 64,000 tokens and sent no code; the second finished. The two tries took 27 minutes and cost $0.65.
- ◐ Tilts towards the pointer, with foil and glare that move with it (partly)
- ◐ The creatures are drawn and the card text is readable (partly)
13 min · 59,018 output tokens (42,254 thinking) · $0.355 for this answer; 27 min and $0.647 over 2 tries
Took 2 tries: sent no code at 64,000 tokens; finished at 64,000 tokens.Billed for 1,438 input tokens, about 1,204 more than the other models for the same prompt. We sent no system prompt, and the extra is there on every one of its requests, so it is text the provider adds itself.
The foil is lovely on its own, a rainbow wash with a dotted pattern and a bright glare that follows the pointer, but it is laid over the card so heavily that the creatures (Dewlet, Flutterbud, Mosskit) cannot be seen, only their names. Clicking the card makes it disappear: the back never shows, and a second click brings the front back. 15 minutes, $0.22.
- ✗ Flips on a click or tap to a designed back
- ✗ The creatures are drawn and the card text is readable
15 min · 36,432 output tokens (20,803 thinking) · $0.219
57 s · 37,779 output tokens (23,785 thinking) · $0.019
Added 9 November 2026.
94 s · 14,964 output tokens · $0.150
Added 13 October 2026.
One answer per model, at each model's default settings unless the card says otherwise, through OpenRouter. If an answer ran out of room or stopped short, we asked again with more room, then with thinking off, and say so. This is a quick look, not a benchmark: run it again and every answer will differ. For measured results, see our benchmarks.
What we checked, by trying each answer ourselves: Tilts towards the pointer, with foil and glare that move with it; Drifts on its own when left alone; Flips on a click or tap to a designed back; Moves between the three cards; The creatures are drawn and the card text is readable. A partial pass counts as half.
GPT-6.1 Sol's set is the one we would print: pale pearlescent cards whose sheen turns from yellow to lilac as they tilt, with crisp line drawings and type that the foil never drowns, and a dark back worth turning over. It took about three minutes and cost $0.12. Claude Opus 5.5 made the most convincing trading cards, with colour-shifting frames, stats and an engraved back, but its glare washes out the art; Claude Fable 5.1 has the loudest foil, at $2.87 the dearest of the first eighteen answers by far. Claude Haiku 5.5 passed every check for $0.025, and DeepSeek V4.1 Flash for under a cent. DeepSeek V4.1 Flash 1017, added on 19 October, also passes every check, with a stronger foil and clearer type than the September version, for $0.074. MiniMax M3.1 Flash, added the same day on OpenRouter's free route, has charming creatures and designed backs, but its foil barely shows on the pale fronts. Mercury 3, added the same day, passes every check too, with a soft purple foil and simple, emoji-like creatures. GPT-6.1 Terra, added on 27 October, passes every check with a quiet pastel foil for $0.051, and Kimi K3.1 Pro, added the same day, has finely drawn creatures on dark cards for $0.42 and 19 minutes; its cards sit small on the page and most of its foil is on the frame, so GPT-6.1 Sol's set stays ahead. Claude Fable 5.2, added on 10 November, passes every check with the richest set on the page: three full-colour creatures on dark cards, a strong rainbow foil and a rosette back. It is the closest rival to Sol's set, and which is better is a matter of taste, loud against quiet. Claude Fable 5.2 took 15 minutes and cost $3.78, so the pick stays where it is.
The foil is where answers went wrong. Qwen3.8 Max laid it on so thick that its creatures vanish, and its cards disappear when flipped. Gemini 3.8 Flash's foil comes out as hard-edged blocks of colour, Grok 4.7's pale pearl makes its text hard to read, and GPT-6 Luna's is so faint that the card hardly looks holographic. This test gave each answer room for 64,000 tokens: Kimi K3 and Mistral Large 4 ran out and finished with 128,000, and Grok sent no code the first time.