Benchmarks / DeckBench / Northgate Homes

Measured by Spring Prompt

Claude Fable 5.1: Responsive repairs: in-house team or renewed contract

For the board of trustees of a housing association, including two tenant board members. The decision it supports: whether to approve £1.2m to set up an in-house repairs team or renew the contract.

Verdict
Not presentable
Deck rating
1,256
Slides
8 (brief: 6-9)
Design quality
62%

Why it is not presentable

  • Layout defect: something off the slide, colliding, too small or too faint to read
  • A slide the judges rated as needing work

In detail

  • Slide 2: 2 text boxes set at 9 pt, too small to read
  • Slide 2: Two text boxes overlap
  • Slide 3: 2 text boxes set at 9 pt, too small to read
  • Slide 4: 2 text boxes set at 9 pt, too small to read
  • Slide 5: A text box set at 9 pt, too small to read
  1. Slide 1 of Claude Fable 5.1's deck
    Slide 1Download slide imagePolished
  2. Slide 2 of Claude Fable 5.1's deck
    Slide 2Download slide imageNeeds work In the third card, the large orange word 'saved' overlaps the grey explanatory text, making both difficult to read.In the third card, the headline '£0.4m a year saved' wraps onto a second line and 'saved' overprints the caption '£3.9m a year in-house vs £4.3m…', making both unreadable
  3. Slide 3 of Claude Fable 5.1's deck
    Slide 3Download slide imagePolished
  4. Slide 4 of Claude Fable 5.1's deck
    Slide 4Download slide imageAcceptable The right-hand panel is text-heavy, with four multi-line bullets and little emphasis within them.The title says 'the adjusted figures say no', but the chart plots only the unadjusted reported line, so the visual shows the October jump the slide argues against
  5. Slide 5 of Claude Fable 5.1's deck
    Slide 5Download slide imagePolished The title wraps to two lines and the orange accent bar collides with the second line, cutting through 'whose'
  6. Slide 6 of Claude Fable 5.1's deck
    Slide 6Download slide imageAcceptable Annual running costs are repeated in the table, chart and callout, adding visual bulk without a distinct role for each.The title wraps to two lines and the orange accent bar collides with 'in about'
  7. Slide 7 of Claude Fable 5.1's deck
    Slide 7Download slide imageAcceptable Both option cards rely on multi-line bullets, making the comparison slower to scan than aligned comparison rows would be.The title wraps to two lines and the orange accent bar collides with 'contract'
  8. Slide 8 of Claude Fable 5.1's deck
    Slide 8Download slide imageAcceptable The title identifies the appendix topic but does not state a takeaway.Numbers are left-aligned rather than right-aligned, which makes the columns harder to compare