Benchmarks / DeckBench / Northgate Homes

Measured by Spring Prompt

Claude Haiku 5.5: Responsive repairs: in-house team or renewed contract

For the board of trustees of a housing association, including two tenant board members. The decision it supports: whether to approve £1.2m to set up an in-house repairs team or renew the contract.

Verdict
Not presentable
Deck rating
1,120
Slides
8 (brief: 6-9)
Design quality
69%

Why it is not presentable

  • Made a material claim the analysis does not support

In detail

  • Slide 4: “That accounts for about 12% of the reported rise.” is not supported by the analysis.
  • Slide 7: “Renewal keeps the current performance.” is not supported by the analysis.
  1. Slide 1 of Claude Haiku 5.5's deck
    Slide 1Download slide imagePolished
  2. Slide 2 of Claude Haiku 5.5's deck
    Slide 2Download slide imageAcceptable The three cards are paragraph-heavy; highlighting the key figures would make the supporting arguments easier to scan.The title wraps to two lines, but the orange accent bar stays at its one-line position, so it sits jammed against the baseline of 'built'.
  3. Slide 3 of Claude Haiku 5.5's deck
    Slide 3Download slide imageAcceptable The final value label, 4150, is crowded against the chart's top border.The '4150' data label overlaps the top border of the plot frame.
  4. Slide 4 of Claude Haiku 5.5's deck
    Slide 4Download slide imageAcceptable The right-hand panel contains four substantial bullets with little differentiation in emphasis.The title wraps to two lines, and the orange accent bar collides with the second line ('backlog'), cutting through its descenders.
  5. Slide 5 of Claude Haiku 5.5's deck
    Slide 5Download slide imagePolished The title wraps to two lines, and the orange accent bar collides with 'among', cutting through its descenders.
  6. Slide 6 of Claude Haiku 5.5's deck
    Slide 6Download slide imageAcceptable The chart, table and bullets repeat the same running-cost comparison, making the slide busier than necessary.The title wraps to two lines, and the orange accent bar collides with 'in about'.
  7. Slide 7 of Claude Haiku 5.5's deck
    Slide 7Download slide imageAcceptable Both comparison panels rely on long bullets rather than a quickly scannable set of matched criteria.The title wraps to two lines, and the orange accent bar collides with 'performance', overlapping the descender of the 'p'.
  8. Slide 8 of Claude Haiku 5.5's deck
    Slide 8Download slide imagePolished