Benchmarks / DeckBench / Northgate Homes
Measured by Spring Prompt
Mistral Medium 3.5: Responsive repairs: in-house team or renewed contract
For the board of trustees of a housing association, including two tenant board members. The decision it supports: whether to approve £1.2m to set up an in-house repairs team or renew the contract.
- Verdict
- Not presentable
- Deck rating
- 585
- Slides
- 7 (brief: 6-9)
- Design quality
- 29%
Why it is not presentable
- Layout defect: something off the slide, colliding, too small or too faint to read
- Quoted a figure the analysis says not to quote
- Made a material claim the analysis does not support
- A slide the judges rated as needing work
In detail
- Slide 4 quotes 3.8: Brakes & Bond's indicative price of £3.8m a year.
- Slide 6: “Greater control over service quality and response times.” is not supported by the analysis.
- Slide 4: “Renew Contract (Indicative Price) | 0 | 3.8 — presents Brakes & Bond's £3.8m indicative price, which the analysis says must not be quoted until procurement has a formal bid, and it shows renewal as cheaper than in-house (£3.9m)” is not supported by the analysis.
- Slide 1: Text too faint against its background (contrast 1.0:1)
- Slide 2: Text too faint against its background (contrast 1.0:1)
- Slide 3: Text too faint against its background (contrast 1.0:1)
- Slide 4: Text too faint against its background (contrast 1.0:1)
- Slide 5: Text too faint against its background (contrast 1.0:1)